Completed
yarnie
2 people found this review helpful
Jul 24, 2012
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 8.0
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Music 10
Rewatch Value 8.0
Evrything was perfect seriously esp story make me fall in love with it! Plus lead actors was my favorite K actor-actress Lee Min Jung & Gong Yoo so ? totaly needed to watch this when ? first saw :D then while watching story become confusing espicialy in the last 2 ep! I always loved Hong sisters dramas but they realy have some serious problems about endings :'(
THE ONLY REASONS THAT I dont regret ? watched this drama while its airing and downloaded all eps in hq IS Lee Min Jung's and Gong Yoo's act! they are so perfect :'o showing all those emotions that easly and have so much chemistry ? just can 'woow' *-* wish to see them together in new dramas

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Naufaltaufik21
1 people found this review helpful
Feb 20, 2014
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 2.0
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 9.0
Rewatch Value 1.0
It's really a nice story but I really hate this drama,because is student-teacher relationship , and the ending was bad :(. All of the cast of this drama was amazing but is really disappointed , I want kang kyung joon be with Suzy and become a main role of drama,he is really pity sleeping in hospital until ending ;((
Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Kalahara
1 people found this review helpful
Nov 5, 2012
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 7.0
Story 8.0
Acting/Cast 10
Music 10
Rewatch Value 5.0
I'm a great fan of the Hong sisters work and for the most part their humor and gift for writing shone through in this. The casting was excelent and the whole drama was riddled with humor and wit. With that being said episodes 14 and 15 leading up to the finale were sort of recapping storyline we had already gone through and the finale episode after so much buildup leading up to the switch back just kinda got swept under a rug and hidden under a time gap. I won't say I was hugely disappinted in this I just think they owed more to the viewer who loved all these characters. I dunno if they ran out of ideas on how to work the ending or what but you wanted more after investing yourself in to 16 episodes.
I loved the basis of this storyline I thought it had such promise for a epic ending it's a shame they kinda just went the route they did.
Overall its a enjoyable drama and you will laugh and cry through it.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
ibisfeather
0 people found this review helpful
Oct 25, 2024
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 10
Story 9.5
Acting/Cast 9.5
Music 8.5
Rewatch Value 10
This review may contain spoilers

Gong Yoo's supra stellar physical acting skills

The Hong Sisters' 8th script, 2012, 16eps at 1hr ea. A wonderful watch, made deceptively simple by a truly sophisticated production. Gong Yoo's supra stellar physical acting skills alone would have made this series way better than the 1988 film Big which supplies the original premise. Not only is GY's performance superior to Tom Hanks', but thank you very much, TH would have withered under 16 hrs of acting and character arc.

Pastiche references to the 80s are common with millenials, but this is a true and subtle loving homage to sitcoms and films of the period by consummate professionals all the way down the line of cast and crew. Directed by Ji Byung Hyun, who did the HS' first script, and by Kim Sung Hoon, whose first series was Dream High, Bae Suzy's debut as a Hallyu star actress.

Suzy has a magnetic screen presence even here in 2012, and although as Mi Ra, the unlikely 2FL, she is about as blunt as a hammer, her own pure sincerity and emotional boldness work well inside this storyline. It is also the nicest foreign cinematic compliment to the essential innocence and idiocy of the American teenager that I have ever seen. Brilliant casting. The other idol actor, who would normally have been the 2ML, spends most of the film in a coma, as his character has migrated to the body of a classic "good son" Korean doctor.

As part of the American homage, not only is the lighting warm and consistently bright and the acting style more naturalistic in the vein of US comedy, but the FL has a loveable, cozy and intact family around which revolve all the other characters, most of whom are written with American connections. Her brother is, I think, the real 2ML opposite Suzy, amidst an absolute storm of romantic connections which background the central storyline.

The HS, in an intelligent loyalty to the genre, often run an underlying theme of romance: the love within an enduring marriage (Chunhyang), teen love (Youre Beautiful), dating conventions (My Girlfriend is a G), sex before marriage? (Warm and Cozy) and the theme of fairytale weddings here in Big.

At first seemingly another naive short-skirted FL, Lee Min Jung's character as written avoids the skewered, frozen and frustrating stereotype current in kdrama recently. Much more easily read by a western audience as representative of the girl who lives in the heart of every woman, her hopeful innocence is one of the factors which helps Big avoid the skeaziness of the '88 film. The other is the relatively minor age gap between an 18-20 yearold and the middle 20s of the substitute teacher. She keeps calling him a kid, which may be a joke about Korean reckoning but is definitely part of her goodhearted naivete and essential moral nature.

Just as Gong Yoo dominates the first part of the series and Suzy 's character rises to the fore in the final dramatic events, MIn Jung's beautiful eyes and Barbra Streisand-like soulful upturned gaze focuses the central part of the series. Her conflicted guilt at two-timing her husband- to-be (the doctor) by falling in love with her de facto husband, a brilliant characterization by Gong Yoo of a moody, rebellious and intelligent American teen in her original fiance's body, seems annoying at first but draws the viewer into the necessary suspension of disbelief.

In short, you will fall in love with Da Ran and her Kyung Joon. This is such a long review that I barely have room to say that GY's physical acting is insane, and the rest of the cast are so sensitive -- example: as a well brought up Korean American the teen is aware of social conventions but tends to automatically evince american behaviors. GY actually DOES that! Da Ran's family notice this but sweetly attribute it to something else...amazing stuff.

ps. The ending isnt perfect but is classic kdrama driven (think about twins...the true lovers do unite! But the now older younger twin looks exactly like his older brother, duh!. The HS often pack some character development into a forced separation in the last two episodes, and indulgence in a little ambiguity is common event in kdrama when tidiness isnt possible. Until recently, the plot of a series is written on the fly after the first few weeks, via negotiation or balancing act between the audience reactions in real time, the scriptwriters original intentions if any, and the director's plans, if any.

The SK television audience has a much higher tolerance for loose ending, in consequence. But now with the internationalization of asian drama on streaming svcs, as drama lengths shorten and regional differences (unfortunately from my sentimental perspective) tend to be ironed out, likewise quick or ambiguous wrap-ups will become less common.

first posted sept 1st, 2024 on Viki

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
bnjminaplebaum
0 people found this review helpful
Feb 24, 2022
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 1
Overall 8.5
Story 8.5
Acting/Cast 8.0
Music 7.5
Rewatch Value 7.0
This review may contain spoilers

Love it when i was a child xd

I really enjoyed watching this when i’m around 14 haha I totally finished watching it and really love gong yoo back then. But when I checked on the reviews and rates, I’m confused why people hated it. But not to care I do really love this drama <3 . I can’t remember the whole story now but I can still feel my heart fluttering as I’m watching this before. I love every characters here. The only thing I got disappointed was the ending, it feels like it’s not the end yet. And so the boy and the doctor didn’t swap their bodies back. I feel bad for the doctor

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Ako
0 people found this review helpful
Jul 25, 2012
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 7.0
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 10
Music 8.0
Rewatch Value 6.0
Since I heard the hong sisters were going to make a drama with Gong Yoo and Lee Min-Jung, I was like totally happy. I'm a big fan of these sisters and I've seen most of their work. The fact thait there was going to be "magical things", the body switch and others, sounded really great to me as I was in a kind of "fantastic drama period" because of Rooftop prince, Queen in hyun's man.. After the first 4 episodes, I was kinda disappointed, I liked it, but I felt like something was missing which I always found in a Hong sisters' drama. And after watching the fifth episode, I began to really really like it. And it went on like that, I was waiting each episode like crazy and was totally addicted ! So I just finished it, I woke up at 7 a.m to see the last episode, I was really confused because everything happened really fast, I think in the context it was so hard to do a great ending as the viewers wanted, I can't come up with something that would make sense as an end ( even if the main subject of this drama doesn't make sense actually .. ). Anyway, I loved the actors, I'm a huge fan of Gong Yoo and I definitely know why, I also love Lee Min-Jung, she's just SO talented and pretty. I loved the character of her brother as well. Ahn Suk Hwan also has a role in Bridal Mask at the same time it's so impressive. I didn't like Suzy much before but she was so cute and funny here. I loved all the background music too. It's not the kind of drama I would watch again entirely but just a few scenes I liked.
So at the moment I think you should watch it since it's part of the "new drama genre" but the drama itself sadly lost most of its essence in the last 4 episodes. It's not a must-watch but if you have time to spare and are looking for something to watch, it can be a good choice.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
TokkiLilyShawol
0 people found this review helpful
Jul 5, 2015
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 8.0
Story 7.0
Acting/Cast 9.0
Music 6.0
Rewatch Value 9.0
Absolutely loved this drama <3 Mainly because it was the first Korean drama that I ever watched. I had just recently discovered Kpop and happen to stumble upon this cute drama on youtube. After watching the first episode I was intrigued so I carried on watching, however some parts of the story did drag on a bit towards ep 9/10 but it was a fun watch. The only thing I disliked about this drama was the ending, it was very confusing, I don't like these types of open endings.. but I guess the writer was torn as well in who to choose.. oh well. I would definitely recommend this drama to anyone looking for a light, fun, fantasy-ish type of drama, its a good watch for the whole family.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Completed
Valentina Ortiz
0 people found this review helpful
Sep 28, 2020
16 of 16 episodes seen
Completed 0
Overall 6.0
Story 6.0
Acting/Cast 8.0
Music 5.0
Rewatch Value 1.0
This review may contain spoilers

Final inexistente

Estaba muy ansiosa de ver esta serie, ya que era la única de las series de Gong Yoo que no había visto y tenia muy buenas críticas, insisto solo la vi por él, me costo mucho encontrarla con subtítulos en español, hasta que por fin lo logré. Y tengo que reconocer que este hombre actúa muy bien, me encanta, tiene un aura especial, espero ansiosa más proyectos de él.
Ahora hable de esta serie, desde el principio me pareció una historia interesante, aunque bastante complicada de resolver, así que tenia mucho miedo que al final no lo resolvieran bien, y como he dicho antes, un mal final echa a perder todo. Por ese motivo esta reseña tiene spoilers, ya que es muy difícil explicar lo que me pasó con ella si no lo cuento.

Una chica que consigue un novio perfecto, lindo inteligente y se van a casar, por alguna razón el anda distante y sin tiempo para ella antes de la boda.
Por otro lado llega un alumno nuevo a la escuela donde ella da clases, lo conoce de una forma peculiar y se hacen mas cercanos. Este chico viene llegando de USA, y quedo huérfano.
Cuento corto, hay un accidente que los dos tan involucrados y el cuerpo del adulto queda con la personalidad del chico y el chico queda en coma en el hospital. Ella es la única que al principio sabe de este cambio .
Suena muy interesante toda la historia sumado a los misterios del dibujo de ambos chicos tienen, y entender cual es la relación entre ellos en su pasado y porque se intercambiaron.
En el medio de todo aparece una amiga del doctor que tiene intereses mas profundos hacia él y la prometida del chico que es un verdadero fastidio y entrometida.
Entonces a través de todos los capítulos comienzan a crear una relación entre la protagonista y el chico en el cuerpo del doctor, como van a solucionar esto? si al final cada uno vuelve a su cuerpo, ella se esta enamorando del chico, con mil culpas por el doctor que era su novio. No veo una solución lógica y decente si lo logran les doy 10 estrellas.

(La música que ponían en cada escena, me tenia obstinada, especialmente porque basado en eso sabias si era algo cómico, algo romántico, etc. y te predisponía a tomar un partido de los que pasaba ahi. Entiendo lo que querían hacer, pero era demasiado evidente y exagerado.
Suzy, me cayo muy bien en Mientras dormías, y fue aceptable en Uncontrollably Fond, aqui la odie desde el principio, que significa eso, es muy buena actriz, el rol le quedo bien hecho. Espero que el próximo que vea de ella no sea tan desagradable).

FINAL
Por lo visto no lo lograron, lo sabía, se metieron en un problema muy grande para conseguir una solución satisfactoria sin que nadie salga dañado y dejando a Gong Yoo de protagonista del final.
Extendieron la historia de muchas manera para llenar los espacios que no tenían para hacer el final. Clarooo, como iban hacer un final sin el protagonista, los guionistas piratearon de lo lindo.
Muy interesante la historia, pero si no la saben terminar no la hagan.
Toda la serie quedo a la expectativa que le iba a decir el doctor antes del accidente, si la amaba o no, y saben que nunca lo dijeron, nunca los mostraron hablando después que despertó, que descaro.
10 min antes de que termine el último capítulo se despiden antes de volver a sus cuerpos, …y 1 año después, se lee un mensaje diciendo que despertaron en sus cuerpos y no recuerdan nada. En serio? Eso es todo?
de esos 10 minutos final 3 minutos fueron usados para mostrar al hermano que sigue sumiso ante a Ma RI, que sigue tratándolo mal, esa historia super plana, que nunca paso nadaaaaa.
Faltando 2 min para terminar, se encuentran, y sorpresa, nunca le muestran la cara a él, intercalan recuerdos de cuando era el otro. Se pasaron, es el colmo de un final de mierda.

Como he dicho siempre si el final es el postre y esta malo, se echa a perder toda la comida, queda un muy mal sabor de boca. No volvería a ver esto nunca más.
Si les da curiosidad ver la maravillosa actuación de Gong Yoo, véanla, aunque les advierto que hay otras mucho mejores.
LES ADVIERTO el final es demasiado malo. Es como si no existiera, como si nunca supieron como resolverlo y lo dejaron asi. Me siento estafada.

Read More

Was this review helpful to you?
Big (2012) poster

Details

Statistics

  • Score: 7.0 (scored by 18,051 users)
  • Ranked: #9421
  • Popularity: #420
  • Watchers: 35,715

Top Contributors

49 edits
20 edits
20 edits
18 edits

Popular Lists

Related lists from users

Recently Watched By