This review may contain spoilers
Great plot story but too much stress and pressure
Honestly, the plot story is good. picking the background story in 1987 when most countries in Asia (my country also) was under a dictatorship that was very conservative, anti-communist and anti-socialist even people at that time only voiced left wings things like labour rights, equality etc, the government can framing that protester as communist and made the basis of justification to oppressing people which is very successfully depicted in this film.But unfortunately for me as an ordinary person who has no expertise in judging a drama (watching drama just look for entertainment), I feel too much stress and pressure especially start from episode 4 until the end. I'm f*cking stressed not only about background conditions like political and interest struggles that happen outside the dormitory but also the main couple relationship between the Female Lead (Yeong Ro) that face the harsh reality and feels betrayed by the Male Lead (Soo Ho) background make it very lacks romance just disappointment until several episodes although finally, the romantic feeling starts to grow again in the next few episodes.
It's not enough that, the suffering continues until the end of the episode and facing the fact that the drama ends sadly for this main couple.
make me feel that the stress and pressure I feel are not worth it at the end of the story because of the complexity that built up within the drama. that's why I can't give 9 or 10 stars overall for this drama and I planned to watch some light and sweet story or get rest for a while after watching this drama.
Was this review helpful to you?
cruel ending
great acting by female lead and male lead. horrible ending for the male lead and female lead. male lead sacrificed his life for his country but his country wanted him dead, disowned him. for the ending, he was shot to death and the female lead need to endure the pain of losing her mother, brother, father (imprisoned) and her lover. wth writer, went through roller coaster of emotion, anxiousness watching this drama only to find out that the ending was downright disappointing and painful. at least be gentle and make the hero alive? the write basically killed all hopeful leading charactersWas this review helpful to you?
Not one to miss out on
I personally did not expect a lot from this drama and to be honest I was hesitant to watch this drama considering the fog of controversies this drama was surrounded by. I totally understand the sensitivities of the South Korean citizens and can see how problematic and insensitive this drama might come off for those that lived through this period of time however for what it's worth when it is viewed from an unbiased point this drama is absolutely edge-of-the-seat riveting.I cannot even imagine the amount of thought and effort that the whole team would have put into creating this drama. We're in the 8th episode and I still have no idea where the story is going. The way the drama is unfolding is a perfect example of clever storytelling. I think we're still too early to pass on whether the plot is a success or not but it has got me thinking about it more than I want to.
In terms of acting, Jung Hae-in stole my heart since he had side character roles and he is the king of melodramas so to see him take up challenging roles like in D.P. and Snowdrop fills me with pride. I see this guy and think "he's one to look out for." He rose up my list so fast so it's fair to say that 90 percent of the reason I am watching this is for him lol.
Now, I read a lot of comments on the net saying Jisoo needs to improve her acting but I can assure y'all that Jisoo has done a stellar job so far so if you're afraid of being disappointed by her don't be because she has done amazing. This isn't to say that she's delivered a performance that is at a veteran level, don't get me wrong but for a rookie actor (literally her first drama) she's done absolutely amazing.
At times her expressions are a little stiff and in terms of micro-expressions and body language she could do better but I'm proud of her for taking up such a difficult role and giving her all.
All in all, the casting is perfect. Shoutout to Kim Hye-yoon and Kim Min-kyu for being so freaking good at portraying their characters.
The OSTs
The intro is so soothing (unlike the drama itself damnit). The track list so far is good. There isn't any I'm particularly obsessed with presently but the soundtrack is really good. Jehwi, one of my favourites, did absolutely amazing as always.
Re-watch value
I cant help but go back and re-watch clips of the drama but maybe that's because I have to compensate for waiting for each episode so for now, a 10.
Overall
Don't skip it. DO NOT. It's so good trust me.
Also R.I.P Kim Mi-soo. you will be remembered and I hope you are at peace now.
Was this review helpful to you?
Good acting earns extraaa stars for this drama.
7 episodes have been released till now. I write this as I wait for the next episode to air.(Might be too soon to comment but I am boreeeddd.)
So far, the drama has been engaging. I wouldn't say it is a great drama but it has been good. The premise of the drama is the good old "falling for the forbidden" trope. However, the story has been different. The actions and mentality of people when faced with difficult situations has been written and portrayed well. The genre of drama is romance and melo, do not expect thrill, which is a mistake I did, lol. I expected some thrill in tense moments and twists. And though there are plot twists, they are not presented in a thrilling way rather in a realistic way. You will like it if you like realistic narration of story. I personally love dRaMaaaa :D
The director has done a good job of making me both love and hate Im Sooho's character. Jung Haein is stunning as usual. I personally love him in negative roles and that was the major reason for starting this drama. His cold, death stares add bonus stars to this drama. You see, I didn't have enough of him as the bad guy in Prison Playbook.
Queen Jisoo portrays the innocence of Yeong-ro with ease. I really really hope she does more dramas. She can carry the idol-actor status as perfectly as IU, Yoona and Suzy do.
The politicians and their wives are all hateful and played to perfection by the veterans.
Yoo In-na is as beautiful as ever. Kim Hye yoon is very convincing as Boon-ok who is annoying and rude but also, pitiful (think Ye-seo from Sky Castle). Jang Seung-jo is "The Good Detective" (hehe, pun intended). All other side characters have been cast perfectly, from Jisoo's roommates to hall director Pi to even the security guy at the dorm. Also, I was happy to see Kim Min-kyu. ;)
Cinematography and set design are amazing as usual.
Overall, it is a one time watch. Although I am sure I'll keep coming back to watch fmvs of Soo-ho and Yeong-ro.
PS : The controversy surrounding the drama is not something an international fan can comment on. That is a topic for Koreans.
Rest in peace, Kim Misoo.
Was this review helpful to you?
Best drama to end 2021 with love and warmth
It's really a very good drama to be watched with your friends and loved ones. you'll find all the gut filling vibes and with the most adorable leads and support. If you are into tragic drama and all that stuff this drama is a perfect one. So far very nice and decent story with unbelievable twits and turnsDo watch and return the love and support to the stars. The bonus part at the end just steels the whole show and makes heart flutter a lot.. The whole drama is full of extremely beautiful visuals .. hope you all like the drama . A perfect drama to be watched again and again
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
not bad, but definitely could have been better!
**edit at the bottom after finishing the whole drama; TLDR: haein is amazing, ending lacked very much and hence points degraded from a previous 10/10 to an 8.5**loved the first 4 episodes a lot, they showed excellent potential for the story and the characters for the future. haein is an incredible actor and you can tell that from the very first scene, and although jisoo has her weaknesses, not bad for a first drama. the romance and the love story that snowdrop has been marketed for was beautiful, sweet, sad and melancholic, however i felt it took a backseat after the first four episodes. i understand that this was their attempt at exploring character dynamics and a painfully slowburn plot, however, i feel like when the screen wasnt on the two of them the love story wasnt there anymore. the plot itself is weak, and slow paced. slow paced plots are excellent if done well, however the weak plot made the episodes a bit monotonous and predictable. the chemistry of the characters and the 80s timeline, that whole potential felt wasted to a point, and i wish they could have done more with that.
people may disagree, saying they dont think the leads should end up together as the ML took wayy too much advantage of the fl, however, i think even though his redemption is in process and hes not quite there yet, he is very much redeemable and i dont hold anything against the fl for forgiving him. heck, mans trying his best, ill give him that. but the slow path to redemption, i personally enjoy. it gave his character realistic depth, he didnt turn a switch and went from god to bad, but is going through the slow process of unlearning learnt behaviours and asking for forgiveness. he is far from it, at this point in the story (epi 13) but hes getting there.
i think to better understand my review for SD, one can compare it with vagabond. vagabond sets the potential for this drama, SD had the potential to be fully action packed in a historical setting with a painfully slow burn romance that could be felt in every scene, whether the characters were there or not. however, i also wont be too critical of SD considering the mass havoc the knetz made in its production, the poor thing was ridden with unprecedented controversies that it very much did not deserve and i can understand and see the diligence with which the plot was written, so as not to offend any party while still making it enjoyable to the public. its a difficult thing, and i cut them some slack. the writers could have done better, but i understand their situation. its still a pretty good effort, and props to them to pull it off despite the controversies the knetz surrounded it by!
genuinely, despite all its flaws and loopholes, all in all, my fangirl heart enjoyed the drama thoroughly. the visuals, the music, the production was very nice. the ost was beautiful, sad, portrayed the characters angst and yearning really well. also im such a sucker for haein, i have to admit his character was more fleshed out by him and the nuances he portrayed rather than what the plot gave him. props to him as an actor, thoroughly enjoyed his performance. im also a sucker for not good not bad, morally grey male leads finding their way in a complicated world, so i genuinely enjoyed this. give this man more roles like these, he can definitely pull them off.
all in all, imperfect, but beautiful and enjoyable.
**EDIT** after finishing the series...
i was very seriously overlooking the flaws and loopholes of this drama in hopes for a fulfilling ending. i feel like the whole thing was pivoted to its ending, it really depended on how cleanly and beautifully they wrapped up the lose threads they oh so beautifully opened in the first 4 episodes, but alas. that wasnt the case, i dont mind tragic ends but this was just poorly done. no matter how much i think i cant excuse it.
all in all, i still loved it, but for much different reasons now: my guy Jung HaeIn carried the show on his beautiful, beautiful back. plotholes aside, i think JHI did an incredible job as SooHo and he deserves all the credit for this. Jisoo did well for her first project as well but my guy HaeIn really stole the show. watch if you want amazing acting on his end, truly incredible. Yoo InNa too in the end. wow.
Was this review helpful to you?
Don't fuckin watch this mind numbingly stupid romanticizing nazi character drama.
worst drama!The writer literally lost her direction on the plot after ep 3. I get it that it's all fiction but at least make a hostage situation realistic. Captors letting go of the characters who broke their rules for numerous time, when they would have been shot to death in one go for even moving an inch in a realistic situation. They truly made a hostage situation a comedic situation through this drama. How can you still fcking love a man who put a gun against your head? Falling for a guy who is a terrorist? Romanticizing the captor and literally a figure like nazi? I mean I would have considered the "romance" in this drama but the two leads barely spent a quality time together that would have led a Romeo And Juliet like tale. No chemistry was shown at all through the story. The stupid romance plot was nothing but forced into the viewers' faces with no chemistry between the leads. One day the fl is beating the ml and cursing him for her brother's death and the next day she's kissing the ml who i remind you is a terrorist. Moreover, it looked like the fl was the only one falling for the ml since the beginning. The ml only wanted to return to his home country to his sister who was waiting for him on the other side without showing us he truly felt for the fl. Everything about the romance was only told but never shown.
Then we have dumb female lead who does nothing but create more problems and always wants to bandage people's wounds which is never a problem to the captors. The captors tell her to stay put, but she never listens and does her own will and the captors literally stays put without any action towards the fl. Like really? They give one warning , then says "it's the final warning" and it repeats till the final episode. I haven't seen 1 single hostage situation where captors are that forgiving and so kind. This whole drama is just dumb and has 0 level of intellect.
Oh and the politics? We all know by reading few articles about the ANSP at the time were dangerous, cruel just bloody. But this drama shows us the ANSP people and other politicians are nothing but clowns. Big fat dumbasses who does nothing but fight amongst themselves like toddlers. Childish i must say. Just save yourselves 17 hours of your precious time and skip this whole ass stupid drama and protect yourselves from losing brain.
Also, the revealing of the "suspense" was so rushed lol. I've never seen a useless suspense reveal as boring as this one. Everything happened in 1 go with no major direction or goal. I laughed out loud when The chef of the hostel and that caretaker of the dormitory was revealed to be the spy of Nk. Like seriously, all they were doing was sit in the corner and starting tantrum like a kid here and there. This whole hostage situation could have ended in few episodes but it continued till mid of episode 16. Or the whole hostage situation could have just started in episode 12 or something while building up characters' personality, romance development between the lead characters (even the supporting characters) and giving backgrounds for the existing characters , their past, rather than haphazardly heaping all these important stuffs in the end of the story.
Ps how i wished it was the fl who died instead of the ml cause of her stupidity and annoying fucked up crying scenes that started from ep 4 and continued till ep 16 final scene and she does nothing but just THAT throughout the whole drama.
Should have gotten worst drama of 2021/22 award! Deserved~
Was this review helpful to you?
Snowdrop - Should you watch it?
First of all. There are some things I should explain/mention about this drama. There are no spoilers, so feel free to read.I decided to post my review after reading up a lot said shortly and then watching the drama with my Korean co-workers. As some might know currently, there are petitions for the drama to stop airing due to claims of historical distortion. The first claims started in the early making of the drama when the plot was announced with a short description of each character. The short descriptions and circulating clips created a big misunderstanding that the drama might glorify ANSP(Agency for National Security Planning) and the military regime and to add fuel to the starting fire the lead female character had a name very similar to a real-life prominent figure from the 1987 protests named Chun Young Cho. In response to the concerns, JTBC changed the name of the female lead from Young Cho to Eun Young Ro. Additionally, the drama also received even more criticism with petitions and lawsuits were filed against it after episodes 1 and 2 aired. In response to the petition and lawsuits, JTBC has released multiple statements that the drama has nothing to do with the pro-democratic movement and the June uprising of 1987. The plot of the drama is set a few months after starting October 1987 and revolved around the presidential elections of 1987, using it as a plot point for the main leads to be able to meet. It is said that due to the close proximity of the events, it is possible for the democratic movement to be mentioned but there will be no disrespectful scenes. Now to the explanation. Is there historical distortion? No, at least not so far. Why did people misunderstand the drama? It's purely JTBC and the makers of the drama at fault, and they are not taking responsibility. Many have tried digging up pasts of the people connected to the drama, and it does not look good. Were they planning to do some distortion or decided to do this for the shock factor? Who knows, but it backfired and cost the drama its ratings. Does the drama glorify ANSP or the regime? No, not at all. You will see throughout the drama it's totally the opposite. Is the male lead posing as a protester or infiltrating the democratic movement? No. The male lead is introduced as a graduate from the University of Berlin and is in South Korea for his thesis. The misunderstanding comes from the fact that in a clip he is seen running past students who are protesting in the background, while a famous protest song is playing, giving a wrong impression. Is the drama good? If the production crew and JTBS did not make the mistakes they did Snowdrop could have easily had a high rating and be in the top 10 dramas of 2021. Despite everything to an unbiased viewer, and someone who has watched EVERY single K-drama from 2021 I can tell you the drama is amazing. I never skipped a scene and wait for every episode impatiently. It's a rare gem with a perfect cast and acting. I had low expectations bc an idol was announced but I can't imagine anyone else in this drama now. The actor couple is perfect. The only reason, why I am giving a 9.5 for the story and not 10 is because ALL of this could have been avoided if JTBC thought a little bit more and never allowed such similarities. The drama has NO historical distortion so far 7 episodes in but it's walking on a thin thread. Honestly, Snowdrop just might be my favorite drama of 2021 but that could be because it was the last drama of 2021. It's definitely up there with Vincenzo and The Red Sleeve for me in my top 3. My suggestion is to leave your reservations and expectations aside and watch it. The drama is 10/10 totally worth it. Will my review stay the same? Well, there is time till the end of the drama and the ending is important. There is plenty of time for the drama to go from 10 to 0. I am definitely concerned that the quality might drop due to the loss of sponsors during filming. In any case, watch it, it's totally worth it. Just remember as it is said at the beginning of the drama all events and characters are fictional.
Was this review helpful to you?
getting better and better with every episode
the starting of ep 1 was pretty normal ,, but as the ep goes on it gets better and better, some political scenes could've been boring but seeing as the story progresses it seems to fit in pretty well ,, the chemistry of main leads from start is amazing ,, and many famous actresses and actors are as side roles so expectations are even more ,, the female lead has a likable personality and the main lead seems to be the reserved kind ,, a bit confuse why it has 8 rating .. can easily be counted in the 9+ rating dramas ,, have high expectations!!!Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Too many plot holes....
I don't know why this drama can have such high ratings, but honestly it has too many issues and very poor writings. And I am just at eps 5.First, why the ANSP (or I don't remember their names) guys keep looking for the MC around the school for days even though they were asked to stop, do they have so much free times ? lol.
It's actually hard to understand why Lee Kang Moo keeps looking after the MC right from the beginning.
Too many stereotypes characters too.
Worst one is the telephone girl lol, why is she willing to put the girls in danger just because of her stupid ego...
The way she found the bag was kinda stupid too. Why the hell the girls want to keep a bag with cloths full of blood ? Seriously they should have gotten rid of this right away... And yet they decide to hide this bag the day they know the telephone girl found out about them... And somehow by coincidence she was stalking them that night... (was she going to keep stalk them until she finds something ? Its not like she knew for the bag)
As for the day Lee Kang actually decides to look again for MC at school, by coincidence he had to go there for some money... What a coincidence. And then they are still clever enough to raid a school full of girls and put them in danger, while somehow being able to get dozen of people with him ...
As for MC, kinda hard to appreciate him when he and his 2 friends treat them like sh*t, its not like he is still alive thanks to some of them...
We actually have another dumb character, Lee Kang ex fiancee .... Why the hell would she shoot when they go pick the tel ??? I mean even if she managed to kill MC, the other 2 would kill Kang and the girls for sure...
Overall the show abuse too much on the coincidences making them pretty frustrating... And even after 5eps we still don't know what MC wants to do...
Was this review helpful to you?
AH-MAZZZZZING!!!
I really love this story. Not because I’m a Jisoo fan but because the acting of this straight from the first scene was breath taking. I mean these people are just pulling on my heart strings. Hurry up and release the rest of the series before I run mad?I really love this story. Not because I’m a Jisoo fan but because the acting of this straight from the first scene was breath taking. I mean these people are just pulling on my heart strings. Hurry up and release the rest of the series before I run mad?
Was this review helpful to you?
