This review may contain spoilers
I think this show was amazing, its story and everything about itI like how there are parts which you cry, which you laugh, which you stop watching to calm down
even though it is super long, its very interesting and everyone who has a chance must watch this whenever they can, but to just say at the end when wang yoo dies and when her child dies you are going to cry so much and it is gonna take a while until you get over it but at the end its history and an amazing show,story,cast and acting
Was this review helpful to you?
I first watched this for JCW and wasn't disappointed at all. In the beginning episodes, I saw lots of resemblance in his character to Park BongSoo from Healer, which was a nice surprise. Literally the only issue I had with this masterpiece was the FL. I couldn't stand the actress. She might be the most stone-faced FL I've ever seen, and her only actual change of expression through the whole drama was staring awkwardly wide eyed and motionless when something surprised her.
Still highly recommended. One of the best dramas of all time.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
It's such good drama and the ending made me cry like a baby.
It's my first historical drama and I was sceptical if I should start this one, but after one episode I was already hooked.
The music was very good, various songs, were very good !
Acting was excellent
10/10
Was this review helpful to you?
Music: Okay, can we just talk about the music? The OST is so beautiful and I've been searching for piano music sheets but it's not there. T^T Just listening to the music makes me think back on the whole drama and I get tears from the music alone. The dynamics and emotions just pour out of the music and it's simply so beautiful. Like even before watching the drama, listen to Main Theme-Empress Ki. BEAUTIFUL
Cast: They did SUCH a great job on casting like each person was MEANT for that role. I was so captured by the acting and this drama that I felt like I was IN the drama. That's why the emotional impact was 10000x more for me.
Was this review helpful to you?
Story:
The story is very well written and has so many twist. I really like how Empress Ki was a strong female lead and she was smart! She actually thought about her actions, didn't let people push her around and she planned smart. The story has everything from love, betrayal, politics, hate, power struggles and so much anguish. It's truly worth the watch.
Acting:
GREAT! Everyone did such a great job. Ha Ji-Won was killing it in this drama. She is a great actress. Ji Chang Wook has completely changed in my eyes. I saw him in healer and he was great also and here he doesn't let me down. He does a great job playing Emperor. Joo Jin-Mo did great also. It's my first time seeing him in a drama. The whole cast did great with the acting overall I could find no flaws. Also Jin Yi-han and Baek Jin-hee did great. This was my first time seeing both these actors and I will look for more of their work.
:
Music was pretty great in this drama. It fits well. I especially like the instrumental.
Rewatch:
I would rewatch even though it's so long! Just so many emotions. (Do I want to go through it all again? :))
Overall:
10/10
Was this review helpful to you?
The emperor that was never a coward.
When I first saw the number of episodes, I thought to myself, am I ready for this. You know the sad empty feeling you get after watching a very good drama. Yea I wasn’t ready for that but then again JCW made me watch it. I’m going to talk about my favorite characters. Firstly tanashiri , she delivered. Like there was no way you wouldn’t hate her character ?. In some ways I could sympathize with her feelings but not her actions. She was purely evil and wanted power like the Queen dowager. In a way it’s actually understandable, because in the palace people did what they had to do just to regain their power and rights. Even though I pitied her, I loved her ending. Then my second favorite character is JCW, and yes I’m part of the fandom. His development arc was so wonderful. His acting skills was superb.The portrayal of emotions and feelings was just wonderful. The hatred he had for tanashiri was transferred to maha who didn’t deserve it. And he regretted his actions later on .He had no one he could really call family till he met sun nyang. This explains the abandonment issues, the tantrums and everything. General banyan was another person who believed in him but got greedy. Truth is the producers made him look like an obsessed lover for the most part of the series but after finding out what Kolta did to him, it’s understandable. For 5 years, he wrote fake love letters and poisoned his mind against the woman he loved. Fed him poison, made him loose his mind. Pushed him to the extreme that he raped her thinking she was cheating on him.( I don’t support the rape) though.He had to go through a lot, carried so much pain and burden for 5 years but still despite that he never gave her up but rather he made her what she was meant to be. I read someone review saying that they weren’t meant to be endgame but if you really watched the series from the beginning. You would remember the intense chemistry or when Wang yu asked if she would like to follow torghon back to yuan and she couldn’t say anything. If she didn’t have feelings, she would have refused besides wang yu was still her master. Even Wang yu noticed the growing chemistry and was jealous ( to think she was still dressed as a man then ) ? or the scene when wang yu proposed and after thinking of the emperor. She chose wang yu because of the betrayal.Thirdly my next character is the empress , she fought so hard for what she believed in . Wang yu was her first love but when she met the emperor. She began to like him and that made wang yu jealous. His betrayal turned her love to hate and she swore vengeance on him. In the palace, she saw another side of him and understood why he couldn’t make decisions and began to fall for him again, but at first she chose wang yu because she hasn’t forgiven him .The scene where she lost her son by falling from a cliff really broke me. You could feel the pain and frustration, seeing all the koryo women die just for nothing changed her. This sparked a new fire in her.
She was ready to fight even if it meant bringing her close to the person she liked before.
Also, I liked Wang yu but he chose his throne over her, not that I fault him though. He was a honourable man , a man of strong beliefs and fought for what he believed in. I really wished he ended up with that other lady that liked him but she died early on. His love relationship with Sun nyang was more of duty. A master to his subject kind of love. He was her first love and yes she still had that soft spot for him and that explains the sadness whenever she saw him. The thought of what could have been if circumstances were different but the emperor was her epic love. She sacrificed a lot for him , saved his life a lot of times and even took poison for him. The love they had was unfathomable yet unconditional.
The Smartest character was tal tal and I see a lot of people shipping him with the female lead but if you observe closely. They had a brotherly kind of love. A familial love, he was her support and wedge. He helped her to make smart decisions I really wished he didn’t die. Watching him kill his uncle was really sad but just made me realize he was indeed a man of his words. He fulfilled the promise he made to his uncle to kill him whenever he became like el temur.
Generally it was a lovely series in all, I liked the political moves and everything. El temur was purely evil. His dying scene sparked a lot of controversy. You would really understand why people made certain decisions, the reason that drove queen dowager and general banyan . Although General banyan was bound to become like him. Right from the beginning he never cared about Justice but only cared about the winning side. That’s why he chose to spare the emperor early on. He chose to make a bet because he believed through him, he could get the power he wanted. To el temur he was just his dog that he used and nothing more . That’s why he decided to take el temur down but later on saw that sun nyang was gaining the Favour of the emperor and high court. That’s why him and the empress dowager didn’t want sun nyang to be empress. They knew how much he loved her and knew she couldn’t be controlled.
One thing I learnt from the series is that you could have so much time yet little time. The ending was just bittersweet. Sun nyang realizing how much she loved the emperor. And the emperor realizing all those 5 years, she truly loved him, and he only believed the lies kolta fed him . At the end Sun nyang fought the battle and she suceeded.
Was this review helpful to you?
even though the story somehow contradicts the history of Empress Ki, it's still awesome. the story isn't really common
Was this review helpful to you?
politics, love, destiny, patriotic ideals.
This drama got off to a cracking start, with fast action, witty dialogue and intriguing political machinations. Yang's story is immediately captivating and entertaining. The narrative continues at a very fast pace and it never gets boring.At around the episode 39 mark the story started falling apart in my view, this is a show that has always had life and death scenarios at every turn and each conflict is quickly followed by another leaving no opportunity for reflection or satisfaction. I started to tire of this cycle and at times the show feels like it creates villains and conflict just for the sake of it with no real impact to the overall narrative.
I was especially disappointed with the lack of meaningful resolution to the love story (and it's product) of Yang and Wang Yoo, it felt as if the show was always trying to push the Tae Hwan / Yang loveline even though the very first episode tells us that she ends up with the Emperor, so what was the harm in fully exploring the separation of Yang and Wang Yoo? It was just very sloppily done and I for one was never convinced that Yang loved the Emperor, her relationship with him was a matter of survival and the best way of achieving her goals.
That being said, the acting in this was excellent by some and ok by others. Ji Chang Wook is very good at portraying the weak, childish and selfish Emperor Tae Hwan, whose character is shown to us in the first episode he actually never changed or improved; his portrayal of this character is so well done that even though I never warmed up to this character, I was moved at times by his suffering and his ultimate helplessness, being Emperor means everyone is always trying to use you for whatever they can get.
Wang Yoo portrayed by Joo Jin Mo is the direct foil to the character of the Emperor. Wang Yoo is everything the Emperor is not, brave, strong, selfless with clear political and patriotic ideals. Wang Yoo is a stoic character and he and Yang share the same ideals and aspirations.
I must give special mention to Wang Yoo's band of merry men especially Eunuch Bang, their loyalty to their King is so heartwarming.
Yeoncheol is another character that is portrayed very effectively, he is convincingly evil as is his daughter Tanashili.
Tal Tal also became a firm favourite of mine, I loved his calm assurance and his formidable intelligence.
The last quarter of this show certainly did not do justice to its first three quarters. It ended on a bit of a wimper, and I was especially outraged at the identity of the villain who was exposed in the last few episodes, this was definitely not a credible plot twist.
I was fully prepared to give this show 10 out of 10, but as the show progressed the score lowered because of the many plot holes and the failure to fully explore some emotional aspects of the relationships between characters, and it also seems that at some point the show was determined to kill off as many characters as possible, which in most cases was redundant.
Music is good and well employed.
Final score 8 out of 10.
Was this review helpful to you?
By far one of the best sageuks!
This is by far one the best sageuks ever made! I was intimidated by its length at first, and I expected the story to drag, but I was very impressed with how tight the writing is and how well all narrative threads are developed and come together by the end.The entire cast is phenomenal, but most importantly, this is a drama that avoids most clichees. Its female characters are not the typical wimpy, submissive women we often see in historical dramas. Yang (brialliantly played by Ji-Won) is self-sufficient and outshines almost every male character in the story! I was also pleasantly surprised by Chang Wook's versatility; he plays the weak-willed (but also possessive) emperor amazingly! And finally, Joo Jin-Mo was born to play the King of Goryeo!
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
but this one is the best story ever i seen
if u miss this drama your not ........
i know its long, its becouse there is no rush endings or scense
this drama can be made in 20 episodes but u cant enjoy the story that much
all negative point of other drama made it special
becouse
1) long drama (its make all dramas to ground but here different)
2) Historical and Tragedy dramas (i can only say perfect in this drama)
3)acting (i can say that u can feel the emotions (best acting)
Was this review helpful to you?
