Most Under-rated dramas? Overrated?

sesimesi_momo wrote: Underrated:
Pick The Stars / Stars Falling from the Sky
Cheongdamdong Alice
1% of Anything

Overrated:
Boys Over Flowers
Coffee Prince
Playful Kiss
City Hunter

I agree! Stars Falling From The Sky is so good, while (especially) Boys Over Flowers and Playful Kiss are really overrated.

underrated: Stars Falling from the Sky 9 ends 2 outs I need romance 2012 overrated: boys over flowers faith to the beautiful you

A lot on your lists are making me sad, especially saying Queen In Hyun's man is overrated.
Underrated:
White Christmas
Alice in Wonder city
God of Study
Myung wol the spy
When love walked in

Overrated:
Coffee prince (it literally took me forever to finish)
Secret Garden (it took months before I actually finished it. Finished after the urging of my friend)
My lovely Kim Sam-soon (I really don't get what's so great about it)
Dream high 2 (there is no way I will finish it; nothing could make me)

I've only completed 44 dramas/specials so far, so this list will need to be updated as I make my way through the things I'm currently watching/plan to watch. It was fun to separate out what I agreed on MDL with and what I didn't. :)

Overrated by MDL Standards:

Kang Koo's Story - Average MDL Rating: 7.7 ; My Rating: 1
Aftermath Season 2 - Average MDL Rating: 7.4 ; My Rating: 2
Aftermath - Average MDL Rating: 7.2 ; My Rating: 2.5
Faith - Average MDL Rating: 8.2 ; My Rating: 2.5
Orange Marmalade - Average MDL Rating: 7 ; My Rating: 3.5
Roy Leh Sanae Rai - Average MDL Rating: 7.4 ; My Rating: 3.5
Hyde, Jekyll, Me - Average MDL Rating: 7.3 ; My Rating: 4
Boys over Flowers - Average MDL Rating: 8 ; My Rating: 4.5
Oh My Venus - Average MDL Rating: 8.3 ; My Rating: 4.5
The Heirs - Average MDL Rating: 7.6 ; My Rating: 5

(The point where I start liking the dramas, but they are still considered overrated by MDL standards)

Tatta Hitotsu no Koi - Average MDL Rating: 7.8 ; My Rating: 5.5
I Remember You - Average MDL Rating: 8.6 ; My Rating: 5.5
Secret Garden - Average MDL Rating: 8.6 ; My Rating: 6.5
Pinocchio - Average MDL Rating: 8.8 ; My Rating: 7
Witch's Romance - Average MDL Rating: 8.2 ; My Rating: 7
A Gentleman's Dignity - Average MDL Rating: 8.5 ; My Rating: 7
Love Me If You Dare - Average MDL Rating: 8.9 ; My Rating: 7
Full House (Thai) - Average MDL Rating: 8.8 ; My Rating: 7.5
Reply 1997 - Average MDL Rating: 8.8 ; My Rating: 7.5
1 Litre of Tears - Average MDL Rating: 9.1 ; My Rating: 7.5


Within 1 Point of Difference:

Noble My Love - Average MDL Rating: 8.1 ; My Rating: 7.5
Coffee Prince - Average MDL Rating: 8.4 ; My Rating: 7.5
49 Days - Average MDL Rating: 8.5 ; My Rating: 7.5
Secret - Average MDL Rating: 8.6 ; My Rating: 8
Fated to Love You - Average MDL Rating: 8.4 ; My Rating: 8
Reply 1994 - Average MDL Rating: 8.2 ; My Rating: 8.5
My Girlfriend is a Gumiho - Average MDL Rating: 8.3 ; My Rating: 8.5
Oh My Ghost - Average MDL Rating: 8.7 ; My Rating: 8.5
City Hunter - Average MDL Rating: 8.7 ; My Rating: 9
Healer - Average MDL Rating: 8.9 ; My Rating: 9
Splash Splash LOVE - Average MDL Rating: 8.9 ; My Rating: 9.5
I Hear Your Voice - Average MDL Rating: 9 ; My Rating: 9.5
Kill Me, Heal Me - Average MDL Rating: 9 ; My Rating: 10
Signal - Average MDL Rating: 9.4 ; My Rating: 10


Underrated by MDL Standards:

Le Jun Kai - Average MDL Rating: 6.9 ; My Rating: 8
Madame Antoine - Average MDL Rating: 7.8 ; My Rating: 9
Cheese in the Trap - Average MDL Rating: 8.1 ; My Rating: 10
It's Okay, That's Love - Average MDL Rating: 8.8 ; My Rating: 10
Master's Sun - Average MDL Rating: 8.9 ; My Rating: 10
Scent of a Woman - Average MDL Rating: 8.3 ; My Rating: 10
The Greatest Love - Average MDL Rating: 8.2 ; My Rating: 10
You Who Came From the Stars - Average MDL Rating: 8.9 ; My Rating: 10
The Princess' Man - Average MDL Rating: 8.7; My Rating: 10
That Winter, The Wind Blows - Average MDL Rating: 8.2; My Rating: 10


My General Opinion of Overrated Dramas:

Boys over Flowers
Oh My Venus
The Heirs
Faith
Secret Garden (Liked it, but didn't feel it warranted the hype)
Pinocchio (Liked it, but didn't feel it warranted the hype)


My General Opinion of Underrated Dramas:

The Greatest Love
Scent of a Woman