Secret Love (2010)

Do you know the answer?

That's the question this movie asked. Not in the end, not in the first or not in some particular scene, they asked it again and again and again throughout the whole show. If you know the answer then you don't have to search for your soulmate or wait for a perfect person and if you don't know the answer then in the end you may be left all alone.

'Secret Love' isn't just a movie about an extramarital affair or about twin brothers who make everything confusing. This movie is about finding the true meaning of love.

The story is twisted, which is about how twin brothers love the same girl and the feelings of the girl for both of them and who would she choose. So this was engaging enough to hook you until the end.

The excitement of first love, the despair of losing them, the guilt of doing something unforgivable, the helplessness of not getting what you deserve, and finally the sadness of losing the tiny existing hope. This movie was full of many kinds of emotions and until the end, maintained its consistency.

The cinematography, music, acting, everything felt so real that it made this story which may seem like a dramatic &/opera type into a real-life heartbreaking story.

I didn't like the female lead solely due to her character in the story as how much she was unsure about her true feelings and making the 'Saving from the Mountain' as her deciding factor for her love. But I can't complain about it as that's one of the important elements of the movie.

Also, I admit I liked those occasional sexy scenes which I shouldn't have(?) Thanks to the creators for taking the love scenes as side elements and focusing more on the story and emotions.

Now coming to the most debatable and confusing part which is, "Who was it in that scene Jin Ho or Jin Woo?"

The first encounter was on a winter day when Yeon Yi greeted him with a heart shape on the glass wall, it was Jin Ho who was sitting as you can see the marine life book on the table. Then when he went away to clean the coffee(?) stain, Older brother Jin Woo came with a gift and formal dress and greeted Yeon Yi.

About the bathtub-loving scene, it was the husband Jin Woo (Many are confusing it with younger brother Jin Ho) as you can see the confused look on his face when Yeon Yi calls him Jin Ho while leaving the bathroom. Also, another proof is that Yeon Yi would never have slept with the husband because of her guilt but she did it thinking it was the younger brother as the ring perfectly fitted his finger. We know while the husband was in the hospital someone mentioned that he had lost so much weight, that's why the ring fitted his finger.

About the ending scene, it's hard to figure out who survived, but the movie creators exactly wanted to do that. On that note, there can be three possible things,

First is, Maybe it's Younger brother Jin Ho who survived. As you heard him narrating the story at the start of the film. Also, the handwriting in the letter he sent to Yeon Yi and the note he left for her about sleeping on the couch while facing the tree is kind of similar and Yeon Yi must have noticed that.

Second is, Maybe it's the husband Jin Woo who survived. As you know he didn't want to return home and forced his younger brother to go back because he thought Yeon Yi would never accept him again as her husband or love partner. Another thing is while he was falling from the bridge he requested his younger brother to take care of his wife. So, on the whole, he didn't want to meet her again and that's why after surviving he lived in a foreign country. Also, the mountain photo he had with him in the end(while sitting in the wheelchair) can be a hint too as he loved mountains.

Third is, It's up to us to decide who survived. None of the above hints, evidence, or clues are definite enough to prove who survived. So it's up to us to decide who Yeon Yi loved or did she love both of them but in a different way?

Again do you know the answer?

Read More