This review may contain spoilers
I JUST WANNA WATCH ONE LEE JONG SUK DRAMA WHERE I DON'T SHED AT LEAST ONE TEAR. PLEASE.
The title. Literally. While You Were Sleeping did it to me. Now W did it. Although there were tears of sadness, there were also tears of happiness. This drama reminded me also that I can't remember the last time I shed a tear of happiness. In the last episode when the FL wakes up in the hospital bed with the ML behind her... when she touches his face... the happy tears flowed. Both tears of sadness and happiness flowed.I don't know why a stand-out moment that I remember from this drama is the fact that when the ML was injured after killing his father-figure and was driving away—the FL switched into the driver's seat because the dude was literally bleeding out, and when she moved to take him out of the driver's seat, she cradled his head, The head cradle killed me.
Was this review helpful to you?
I can't give a 10 though, for 2 reasons:
1. The first show, for me, with Lee Jong Suk. At the beginning, I simply thought that I didn't like his acting choices most of the times. However, I saw him in other shows after this one and he grew up on me a lot, as an actor, therefore I guess that the problem lies in the way he's been directed in certain scenes. The same goes for Han Hyo Joo.
2. While absolutely captivating in the beginning, the plot gets quite convoluted towards the final episodes, and not always organically. It's like writers felt the need to make it pointlessly complicated.
Even so, I recommend it because it's something really uncommon to watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
Cute Girls and Guys: check
Clowns and Trolls: check
Romance and Acrion: check
Fairly original: check
Overall Fan service: check
Cons:
Not immersive due to few characters and episodes
Not bullet proof
No good OST (BIG one)
Slightly rush / Story ran dry
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Don’t expect romantic romance here
Took me a while to find the time and initiative to watch this series. I had it saved to watch because of Lee Jong Suk. I am more of a historical period fanatic and to watch other genre, I would have to have a good catalyst (e.g. favorite actress, cute actor, etc).So….on we go.
The plot is interesting enough for me so I invested time to watch it. Jong Suk didn’t disappoint with his charming and beautiful face. He can act too so it’s a plus.
Romance there was an attempt for it but seemed like the Director drastically failed to satisfy the audience. It could have evolved better that could have given this series a great push up.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I was extremely excited to see this drama because the story itself caught my attention for being so creative. Who wouldn't want to go from their regular normal life and instead jump into the world of their favorite comic book, web toon or drama. Where do I sign up? Of course, if Lee Jong Suk is one of the MCs even better. First, I'd like to say their animation/webtoon team did an incredible job. As you watch the show you will really fall in love with the flawless drawings. During the special of this drama, you'll get to see how challenging it was to draw and film the transitions between both worlds. Though there were several themes to keep viewers interested. I wish there had been more character development. I don't think the support roles really had a purpose. At times, I feel they were all on standby or just chess pieces when a hole needed to be plugged in the narrative.
I do appreciate that the sparks between Kang Cheoul and Yeon Joo begun right of the first few episodes. It is so common in dramas to have viewers anxiously wait for the main leads to either kiss or just simply hold hands. This was a sweet romance that offered a break from the chaos and more tensed/life threatening scenes.
There were some parts that I personally found unnecessary. For instance, why is the father all of a sudden under the villain/murderer's control? I understand the villain took his face but do not comprehend the reason the father is just doing everything he is told. Afterwards, when Yeon Joo's father ends up in the manga world. He is once again not himself and turns into a murderer instead. Isn't there already enough villains in the drama? Also, towards the last few episodes they bring Kang Cheoul's bodyguard and friend back. But, at one point I asked myself. How long is he going to be in the car for before he reaches a destination where he can help out? He went from a state of being drugged and needing urgent care to driving aimlessly in a car and picking up phone calls. While his friend was dying and Oh Sung Moo is off murdering someone again on the tablet. These are just minor scenes so it doesn't impact the overall plot really. But, at one point I just wanted Kang Cheoul to stop dying. Again, I think the thought behind the plot was creative. But, I felt some parts did not have substance or were dragged on for too long.
Regardless, I am glad I watched this drama and do recommend you give it a try!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Too repetitive
I had to rate this drama lower once I finished it. It started out SO strong, but there was so much repetition that it was frustrating. This show could have been so much tighter if there were fewer jumps and fewer episodes. It got to the point that I was, "Here we go again." It also would have been better if the coloring in the comic world would have been different somehow. It was really hard to track which world they were in. I felt like the ending of the show (the last few episodes) just kept wandering, because they didn't know how to end it. By the time it did end, I didn't much care, I was just glad it was over. Highlights of the show? The two of them together at the beginning when they were getting to know one another. Lee Jong Suk was even more emotionless than he usually is.Was this review helpful to you?
This was acutally the drama that made me fall in love with lee jong suk!! Both lee jong suk and han hyo joo portrayed their characters very well + the kiss scene in the police station was my favourite scene it was sooo good HAHAHA
Was this review helpful to you?
Storyline Issues
Started on 9/18/2020, finished on 9/25/2020. After pondering about this show for almost a year, this review is my verdict.Overall: 8.5/10
The Story: 6.5 out of 10.
The premise was charming, but the execution was not. (((((Slight spoiler: I disliked the memory loss plot, as it was pointless and made simply for a longer story. It is also cheezy and cliché in my opinion.))))) No spoiler version: the ending was not as quick-paced and riveting as the first half. The plot was dragging extremely. The writer conveniently writes twists so that the plot moves smoothly, but it is not done well. It is messy and illogical. It felt like the writer could not think of anything else, something that would tie seamlessly into the beginning information.
The Acting/Cast: 8.5 out of 10.
Although I was sort of annoyed with the female lead’s (Han Hyo Joo’s) acting, it is bearable. The male lead’s (Lee Jong Suk’s) acting was just okay as well. I liked the cast of the male and female actors. They had great romance and chemistry. The acting that I enjoyed was of the female lead’s dad (Kim Eui Sang). His acting was phenomenal and made up for the mediocre acting. I also enjoyed the bodygaurd (Lee Tae Hwan) and the acting of the female lead’s brother (Lee Si Eon).
The Music: 9.5 out of 10.
Although the music is not revolutionary, hearing the music gives me nostalgia and memories of this show. I loved the main theme of the show, and the music was placed well with the show.
The Rewatch Value: 10 out of 10.
This Rewatch Value plays a big factor in the rating of this show. Although the story was not that great, the suspense and emotions are overwhelming. This show can be watched multiple times, unlike other shows. At the moment, you will love this show immensely. This show is very charming.
Conclusion:
W is a show with a questionable plot and writing, but amazing emotions and writing. It’s an essential show to watch, just for the feels. If the writing and acting were better, this show could easily be a 10 or 9 out of 10 (an 8.8 or 8.7 as of MDL ratings). The writing/plot is a let-down.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Their relationship was so cringy and cute but at the same time SADDDD????????????. The way they don't know how long they'll get to be together and their heart wrecking bc they don't know what'll happen to each other was just.....*sigh. Unbelievable. The ending....omg!!! U have no idea how sad I was. I literally cried so much.
This was the first drama I've watched with lee Jong suk and I gotta admit....he's pretty good. Han hye joo....this was also my first time seeing her in a drama and idk....she's OKEY??? Idk if it's just in this drama but when she cries......SHE DOESNT HAVE TEARS!!! (She does for some scenes) but still.....I kinda got annoyed. Other than that....she was alg. The supporting leads were the BOMB!!! I just can't not leave them out.
I would love to rewatch this drama. Like srsly....I would. But I usually don't rewatch dramas. This might be the problem for other pp as well.....but bc I don't have enough time!!!! I mean....how many new dramas are coming out right??? I just can't miss them out.
I really liked this drama but idk....why I'm giving it a rating of 8. I can't give my reason but it just seems right there.
Was this review helpful to you?
Its a great Kdrama to watch!
This is my second Kdrama. I watched some spoilers in Chinese Tik Tok. It gave me a feeling that this is great drama, it is! Its an amazing Kdrama to watch if your a starter on Kdramas. I love the actors and actresses they chose for this drama! I was curious on the spoilers they gave me on the Chinese Tik Tok, so I wanted to watch it. This Kdrama is good for all ages, but if you don't like watching about Crime or Murdering, I don't suggest it. I didn't know this is a drama about Crime even after I found out I kept watching it, because the romance was amazing. I suggest you to watch this drama on Viki, because its free.Was this review helpful to you?
