Acting/Cast: The acting done by the cast was better than I've seen in most dramas. To say it was good is an understatement, there was such genuine emotion in each scene and it all felt very real. L and Yoon So Hee did such a great job with their characters and their relationship. The only thing that actually bugged me was about Taks character. At first, I really wasn't into Tak. I wasn't sure how he could turn into a complete jerk, even through such stress. It did frustrate me, but it was nice to see an imperfect character get knocked back to his senses.
Music: I'm really not trying to overdo this review with more compliments than it deserves, but the OST in this mini series was so note worthy. The soundtrack was so great to listen to, and it fit the band and the vibe of the show very well. I especially liked the last song, One More Time, I felt that song was absolutely perfect to finish the drama off.
Re-watch Value: I don't re-watch dramas a lot, especially ones with complex stories. I'd rather re-watch shows where all you have to do is laugh and smile. As good as this was, I might just save it as a memory, I don't think I'll re-watch it all by myself. With a friend however, I can totally do that.
Overall: I wanted to give this drama a 9.5 for how I felt about it after just watching it, but after some thinking, I gave it a 9 for everything I said above. With the ratings and the other review, you might think on skipping this one, but I'm here to say that this is a mini series worth watching. It's a 4 hour long ride, so if you feel like it's not you're thing early on, give it a chance to prove itself.
Was this review helpful to you?
From first impressions, this drama may seem like a very light-hearted love story between 2 youths. However, as each episode unfolds, you realize how much depth this story surprisingly has. The story itself has does have some repetitions - at first, it seemed like bad editing, but as you continue, you will soon realize more and more, that the story was made this way on purpose to send the right message. I was very surprised of how a simple on-the-surface plot can be transformed into a feels-train with its hidden complexity. Needless to say, this is a must-watch imo
CHARACTERS / ACTING
This drama really only focuses on one character - Yoo Tak, which at first seemed like a generic character.. and he actually is. As someone who enjoys music, Yoo Tak is very relatable and you will see how he makes mistakes not just for the sake of drama. Among L's work, this is definitely one of the better roles he does done. The lead actress also did very well on her character.
MUSIC
The music in this mini-series is absolutely mesmerizing! There are a few scenes in this drama where nothing is actually presented visually - but the music coupled the situation so well that it was actually driving the story and gave it life and meaning. Particularly, there's a light guitar track with some vocals that really enhanced the experience.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Ending explained in my Point of view
A really different drama where the usual cliches doesn't give you similar vibes. A MUST WATCH!!It has its own story to tell - Love is all about your efforts, even efforts fail sometimes and so love can end too.
Yoo Tak seems like a jerk in first 2 episodes, but then before you realise you start to empathize with him as he gets desperate and helpless while trying to save his girlfriend. The same day repeats yet it is not the same as Yoo tak is also not the same. He tries everything in his might to keep her alive but gets failed everytime until the last episode which makes this drama more unique.
Its like an another loop is formed in the loop.1st loop is Da In would die when Tak's love for her will be over, but at the same time he should become happy. But he doesn't become happy and the same day repeats. In the last episode, he was happy while dying with her so the day should not repeat itself again. But another loop gets created coz Tak was so much in love with her that he was ready to die with her. so Da In should not die.
It created dilemma for Reaper girl so she changed their fate.
It is an open ending whether they would end up together or live separate lives. The hint was in the last song - "we have to walk our own paths."
really loved the acting of both L and Yoon so hee. Both make their chemistry perfect for the plot. I wish to see them again as a lead pair. (Though they acted again in Emperor of the mask, they weren't a pair.)
Songs are really amazing - music and lyrics too. I can hear them on repeat whole week.
I had watched only 3 episodes and kept this drama on hold for almost a year. I am really glad I gave this drama a second chance. Really worth it. Don't make the starting episodes hesitate you.
Was this review helpful to you?
Yoo Tak is such a jerk at the beginning - disillusioned with life and empty inside, and taking it out on everyone around him. And this show takes him, and the viewers, on a rollercoaster of a ride. The depth to this show is astounding. It starts out pretty light, with Yoo Tak doing what most people say they'd do in this kind of situation and living it up, but the longer the show goes on the more it pulls at your heart and makes you care So Much for the characters. This show is an emotional tidal wave. The lessons Yoo Tak learns are so hard but so vital and I loved every moment of watching him learn them.
The acting is phenomenal as well. Like wow. L displays the spectrum of emotions, from the highest of highs to the lowest of lows; love, depression, grief, regret, happiness, optimism, hope, hopelessness, anger, acceptance, and all the chaotic shades that blend them together. And Yoon So Hee portrays Da In in such a realistic way. I never doubted the way these two felt, about life or about each other.
As a show about an Indie band, you can expect that the OST for the show is pretty great, and it really is. Music is used wonderfully in this. It never threw me out of the plot or cringe because it didn't fit. It doesn't drown out what's happening in the show or fade to the background.
I went into this show confused and not expecting much, and came out the other side listing it as one of my favorite kdramas and recommending it to anyone I know who watches kdramas (or might, with enough persuasion, watch them).
Was this review helpful to you?
The story centers around the relationship between Tak and Da In and how far their love really goes. As Tak relives the same day over and over, he realizes that Da In is at the epicenter of it. Although it does have its cliches, the story impacts your heart strings on how Tak truly opens his eyes to the girl in front of him. It portrays their love as a rocky rollercoaster that finds its end, in it's own twist and turns. It brings along flashbacks that show how they first met and how their love slowly blossomed, which I believe added to the ending of the story, one that I was surely not expecting. Love and heartbreak are a destined pair for this romance, and its something you don't want to miss in a way.
NOTE: you will cry, at least I did.
The acting, oh the acting. I've known L as a member of INFINITE and an amazing actor - he didn't disappoint me here either. He portrays Tak so perfectly in every way while executing the emotion of the character with precision. I also can't forget Yoon So Hee who plays Da In. She does have moments (for me) where her acting is kind of bland and basic but then she slaps me back in the face with spectacular acting. The role of Da In and Yoo Tak surely wouldn't be the same without these two, that's for sure.
I'm not really a indie or rock person but boy did this drama turn me right around. The soundtrack per say is filled with amazing songs that I will be listening on repeat (as I ugly cry) for a while. L has a blessed voice and its a blessed part of this drama that he plays the lead singer of the band.
As for rewatch value, I always say "I don't usually watch dramas again but this drama-" but I actually am not kidding with this one. It's got this spark that drew me to it (as I hope it will to you) that just wants to replay in my head no matter what I do. So yes, this is personally a drama that I would gladly rewatch.
To end this review, like I do with all of my reviews, I encourage you to watch the drama yourself.
Was this review helpful to you?
I did, like many other people, come into this drama because I love Myungsoo. It was a short drama and I was struggling to choose something to watch so I gave it a go, not expecting much, especially since the only way I could find to watch it on was some blurry version on YouTube (as I don't have Netflix). Instead, I came out this drama not regretting a moment that I spent watching this. Yes, my fangirl heart was fulfilled with lots of kiss scenes but truly, what made me continue was the fact that I was enjoying the story's progression. The only letdown in that regard was that it was a bit slow for my liking. It was predictable what was going to happen next so I wanted it to continue quickly but I can accept why others may disagree with me in that regard. The story was not too slow that it hindered the plot at all, in fact it appeared intentional, but I feel that you could skim through each episode to get the general gist of what's going on instead of watching the whole thing and still enjoy it as much.
The ending reminded me a lot of the anime film 'Kimi no na wa' (which I highly recommend if you haven't watched). An ending it is essential to take into account when considering what makes a good drama. The ending is a major deciding factor in the memorability of a drama. I feel that these sort of final scenes, which are open to the interpretation of the viewer, does exactly this - encouraging remembrance long after the person has moved on to other dramas. Another point surrounding the ending that I would like to mention, is that in this kind of circumstances, with a plot written as it is, a happy ending that does not feel too forced by the writers is close to impossible. This bittersweet type of ending fits with the story and is perfect on occasions like this. The watcher does not feel too unsatisfied but also does not feel that if the drama was stretched in order for the audience to be pleased.
I thank you for taking the time to read my review. If you are considering this drama, I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
Was this review helpful to you?
A MUST WATCH
This drama hit me differently.It is not an ordinary cliché drama, it goes so much deeper and lets you think about it even after a long time...
In the beginning I couldn't even imagine that this short 4 hours long drama could made me that sentimental. The main character Yoo-Tan really annoyed me in the first episode. But then... everything changed all of a sudden. I even cried in episode two.
It was one of the best dramas I've watched so far, but still, I think I won't rewatch it all by myself because the plot is so powerful and deep... It wouldn't hit me the same.
One sad thing about the drama is that you won't get to listen to the OSTs because the producers never released them:( The music is beautiful, though.
So, if you're considering whether to watch it or not, DO IT! It is so worth it.
Was this review helpful to you?
So, what do I mean by that?
I mean you skip the whole shebang of the two main leads meeting, possibly hating each other before falling in the end. It has none of that. It skips the dull part and jumps into the important part. Also, of all the romance dramas I've watched, I think this is the most un-cheesy in my collection. The romantic moments where they do say cheesy stuff didn't feel cheesy to me at all.
It was highly enjoyable to watch. Normally, this genre can be easy-to-watch and lighthearted, and some may disagree when I say it wasn't lighthearted at all. The drama had very dark themes ranging from a tough time in high school, battling for your own survival while dealing with the thought of death and learning to appreciate even the dullest/most common moments in life. It had multiple deep meanings and it portrayed them beautifully.
So, should you watch this? Normally when reviewing I leave a few pointers at the end for you to see whether or not this drama is worth your time, this is no exception.
You'll like this if:
- You like a touching romance with a realistic view on love (doesn't sugar-coat it).
- You don't mind the musical themes. (It's was a plus in my book)
- A mature relationship that doesn't need "small accidents" like falling/tripping into your significant other's arms or cheesiness to work.
- You want to see a drama that skips the falling-in-love part.
- Likes to see a good, well worked-out character development in both leads.
- Want to watch something short --> Only has 8 x 30 minutes episodes.
- Great acting.
Was this review helpful to you?
THE STORY
I don't even know how to describe it without spoiling the show. After reading the comments, I thought the ending would be bad but it wasn't as bad as I thought it would be. In the beginning, it seems like it's the same as every time slip drama you've seen before. But they actually made changes to make it unique in it's own. way.
THE ACTING
I liked all the characters. I love L. I agree with the comment that he needs to be in more dramas where he is the main lead. The girl is pretty good too. The little girl, who plays angel demon, I love her. She's so cute. Of course, Kang Nam Gil, I love it when he plays the lovable dad.
THE MUSIC
I love the OST. I can listen to it over and over. Infinite is one of my favorite bands and Myungsoo aka L is my first bias in the group.
REWATCH VALUE
I can definitely see myself re-watching this. Even though I cried multiple times, I think the story is short enough that I can revisit it later on.
OVERALL
I gave it a 9 because I didn't feel like it's the best drama I've seen. If you're not ready to commit to a regular long drama, then I definitely recommend watching this. It's short and sweet.
Was this review helpful to you?
what you will see in this drama:
*realistic romance/relationship - love can fade after years, also we often don't value people we love until we don't loose them..
*even good people can be rude and selfish, can be bad boyfriends or friends, they can be tired from difficulties of life, because of they can be not kind, not supportive, not nice all the time... this is real life person, normal person, ML who isn't painted all in beautiful colors because he is ML of the drama, also that doesn't mean he is "bad guy who will become good" kind of character, he is just normal guy who will good and not so good time after time, who will learn lessons from his mistakes
*normal/realistic relationships, friend who can choose better life over his friends, son who hasn't good relationship to his father, though father isn't bad one, musician who is tired after failures.
*in love/relationship one person loves more, it's very often and that one can be female, though in 99% dramas guys love FL so deeply, but in real life, love is more complex thing.
*emotions and characters that you feel and believe, they are like you or some your friend, they are real humans.
*real chemistry and good acting, I mean not oscar worthy great performance, but acting that make you believe, like you are looking at real story and people.
*great cinematography and music
*not predictable story, you wont be bored and you wont know what will happen, so until the end it is interesting and not filled with unnecessary scenes or characters.
yes, there are some plot holes, or not so logical things, but it is kind of phantasy and doesn't have to be everything strict in physical laws. more important is emotional development of characters, their minds and story, which is made great!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Bittersweet Short Drama on Letting People Go
I'll try to spoil as little as possible. I think for the type of storyline, length, and cast this was a good watch! Side note: I have to be honest and tell you guys I cried like a baby watching this. I watched this a few years back, but I remember the storyline and my feelings quite well. I think I cried a lot in this drama because I looked deeper into the drama theme of letting people go. I was probably at a point in my life where I needed to see this message, and it hit me good.STORY
Yoo Tan is in a band with his childhood friends and girlfriend Moon Da In. They are not doing well as a band, and he's in a slump. He decides to join a music label. Once he gets into the label, he casts away his bandmates and girlfriend since he is tired of his old life and wants more. He soon finds that the new path he paved for himself isn't as luxurious as he wanted it to be. He goes back to his old life to finds out that it can never the same anymore.
It's a cliche plot of a boy casting aside a girl and then regrets it, with some fantasy elements thrown in. However, when one looks past the cliche, the deeper themes of the story that gets told is touching. I think everyone can relate to Yoo Tan and his journey with his music passion. When one works so hard for something to succeed and it doesn't go well, one will be stuck in a stage where we question the worth of our passion, how much time was spent on it, and if its worth pursuing. It is only then that we let our own desires make the call. Then we have our lead's relationship that's not as pretty that it once was. We see a relationship of a couple that started out sweet and how it dies out because of lack of care for the relationship. Then only through this time loop will we see the all the desperation that an individual is willing to do for what he/she desires. The theme of letting things go was well written. The regrets, the denial, and eventually the acceptance.
ACTING-CAST-CHARACTERS
Kim Myungsoo (aka L to our Inspirits) performed a lot better than I expected him to do. Especially during this time of his career. I've seen him in Shut up Flower Boy Band, and this felt like a massive step in performance. There were a few moments where I did feel awkward with his acting. However, it wasn't something that would sway me away from the story. I've seen Yoon So Hee in My Love Eun Dong, and I think she's a decent actress. I feel like they had good chemistry together as leads, and I definitely felt their emotions that they were trying to portray.
MUSIC
It's a drama about a band, so obviously, we get some music in here. The best one would have to be the main ost by Kim Myungsoo himself. The song embodies the whole drama and the stages of grief. The lyrics are a push and pull of how the protagonist feels.
RE-WATCH VALUE
I re-watched this at least twice already. It's eight episodes at 30 minutes each. It's a well-done storyline on a cliche trope that doesn't feel like it's getting dragged on. I'd recommend this to anyone who likes a lighter feel of time loop dramas, but one with more depth to it.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
First let me say that I decided to watch this as the episodes are short and there’s only 8 of them. Let’s begin on my thoughts of the first episode. It was basically a cliche that I swear I’ve seen multiple times in a show with a guy wanting to accomplish his dreams and have to let a girl go only to have the day repeat over. With the first episode I already don’t like the main character which I’m sure everyone would be as he’s a complete asshole to everyone. Basically what I’m saying is I already don’t like the show, based on the first episode. At this point I can already see how this shows gonna end based on the first episode. Right now I’m not impressed. Also some of the perspectives on the camera work really bother me and seem unnecessary. Final thoughts after finishing the drama. The show got better overtime and turned out to be something different than what I expected, but the last episode soiled it for me. It made no sense as it moved onto the next day and she was still alive, but everything was different. Why would that grim reaper literally make them go through all that just to be like ya know what she lives onto the next day, but y’all don’t know each other and have to meet again. It defeated the whole purpose of the show. He went through all that trouble and the ending was like that. I don’t understand why they whole show was like “you can’t save her it’s her fate” for the last episode to be a slap in the face. I recommend to stop watching when they jump from the bunggy cord in the last episode. It’s more satisfying to stop their then finish the last episode.
Was this review helpful to you?
