The acting is wonderfully done by all parties involved. The main characters felt very real and complex and very clearly grows as the story progresses without loosing the core of who they are. The side characters were also interesting in their own way, but remains in the background in favor for the main leads. Despite this leading to the side-characters being almost forgotten, i think it was the right choice to focus on the main storyline. More often than not, dramas tend to try to tell too many stories at once and because of this the main storyline suffers.
The music in this drama is not only beautiful in itself, but fits perfectly into the drama and enhances the impact of the scenes.
In summary: great performances, wonderful music and a captivating story. What more could you wish for?
Was this review helpful to you?
It's my first drama with Yoo Ah In and I was ashamed of myself about how can I miss him ... He's so good looking and I've just fallen for his acting ! I will go to see Six Flying Dragons now ;)
Was this review helpful to you?
Unique warm and genius!
A great watch for romance lovers. Although, I’m disappointed as I thought this was a time - travel scifi instead of past life - recarnation.Story (8.5/10)
Such an unique story that I have never seen before. It’s the best part of the drama. In this we get to see how activists struggled and sacrificed to liberate south korea. A mixture of biter sweet romance enhanced the plot-line. The story of past life was great.
Ngl the story is really was really slow paced. To me, the plot went boring - interesting - boring - interesting. I wasn’t really thrilled with the whole series but still carried out. Last two episodes were best to be specific.
Acting (8.0/10)
Actors played out their characters perfectly. Specially the leads! Great chemistry between three friends.
Music (5.0/ 10)
Music and osts were so-so.
Rewatch value (1/10)
Very low. I wouldn’t watch it again.
Overall (7/10)
As I said if you’re into purely romance series you’ll enjoy.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This is a heavy drama, a real good oneWhat bothered me much and made me deduct from the rate that I didn't find the FL fits the role
Older than both ML' s and it was extremely obvious while she supposed to be younger
No chemistry between her and both male leads
She wasn't a light character in my opinion
Although she was a good actress
But I couldn't feel her in this role
that's what I felt
Except that, the drama was really amazing
Well connected events for both stories
Both stories were going parallel to each other
There were character development
they didnt left any event during the whole drama witout being explained,
As they did most of the time, dropping events without being explained
No flaws
Strong plot
I was so sad only for the end of 1930 story
It broke my heart
I was shocked when I found shin yool betrayed hwi young and his country
I couldn't hold myself
I found myself spitting on him LOL
There were lots of comic scenes
The ghost was cute
Their bromance was cute also
The end of the main story were cute and satisfying
Highly recommended
Was this review helpful to you?
When I first started I thought the drama was going to be cheesy and boring, but as you get to see their past life it pulls you in, with wanting to know the whole story.
It’s a very sad ending for what happened in the past, but they all had to go somehow for them to all end up in the present together.
At first I wanted Ryu Soo Hyun and Shin Yool together. They both seemed to fit better , but underneath it all it was Seo Hwi Young that had strong emotions for her, but chose not to express them in front of everyone.
For Han Se Joo I did not like his haircut. It was way too short. I liked his hair when he was playing Seo Hwi Young.
My first reaction to Baek Tae Min was that he was an abuser. It became very clear of what type of person he was when he threw his cat. I myself am a cat lover so I almost stopped watching the show because of him. I am glad that I stayed with it though.
Was this review helpful to you?
Slow first half, amazing latter half
Watching the first half of this drama was very slow-paced and really focused on setting the plot and characters up. I get that it takes time before you really get into a drama or for the plot to start rolling, but for me, it did not get interesting until Episode 10. I was literally giving up on this drama and I kept asking my sister if it was going to get interesting. Episode 5 apparently is where most people started to like the drama. It had an interesting cliffhanger but then lost me again within the next episode. This drama could’ve easily been squished into 10-12 episodes rather than 16. Overall, I still gave this an 8 due to the cinematography & production, OST and the second half.From Episode 10 we get to see how the plot unravels and how our 3 MCs are all connected from their past lives. It was fun to watch. I didn’t feel bored from Episode 10 onwards. I’m really a fan of dramas that have the concept of time travel and history incorporated in it. So every time they would show flashbacks of their past lives I would get excited. I also loved that we got to see the bond/friendship between the 3 MCs in the latter half that we didn’t really get to see in the first half.
The OST I’d say is top-notch and one of the most underrated!! Definitely worth adding to your playlist after you finish watching this drama. Satellite (a fan favourite) and Writing Our Stories were my faves from the soundtrack but they’re all good!
If you have doubts watching this drama, I suggest for you to give it a try! It’s really for those who are patient and can handle slow-paced dramas. Since I got bored until Episode 8, what I did was I only watched 1-2 episodes a day or whenever I had time to watch it. I didn’t pressure myself to binge-watch it or keep going just to get it done. It is worth watching from Episode 10 though, well at least in my case, but it could be different for you. I know that not getting invested in a drama by Episode 5 is discouraging but for those who love books, time travel and past lives this drama is for you!
Was this review helpful to you?
I bawled like a baby
I absolutely love the relationships in this show. The friendship that transcends time is absolutely beautiful. The flashbacks to the past life always had me guessing, and were absolutely beautiful. The plot about the modern life does drag considerably towards the middle; I almost stopped watching. However, the last few episodes were completely worth it. This is definitely one of the top "made me cry" k-dramas I have ever watched just for the past life story alone.Admittedly, I tried rewatching it. The rewatch value is really low because it's the mystery and past life scenes that really push you through some of the dragging portions. However, the guessing game that makes this drama so suspenseful is lost in a rewatch. The past life scenes alone though I could rewatch to no end.
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the best korean drama CT
I dont know how to discribe this dramareally no word can match it
if can say one word
i will say BEST
you can not find any mistake and annyoing
in this drama
story is really uinque
acting is unmatchablle
ending was perfectist in all korean drama
ost is unhelpfull
perfect in all
and abot genre s
it is conatin all genres and ina perfect way
romance
fantasy
Mysterious
comedy
action
historical
little horror
little Thriller
its all thing than you like it
make you watch if u lik any type of drama
romance
bromance
tringle love
nattion matter nestologic
family matter
self mading
betrial
unsocible cant trust any one
Thriling
all of thing
do not search to any thing abot it
words can not help
just watch it
till ep 4 and 5
you will be hookd
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Love is difficult no matter what the era
Love is difficult no matter what the era. I will give up on her in my next life. Let me save her in this one. These are but a few lines from this drama that pierced my heart to bits. Love makes us move. Love endures. Love prevails.The opening first episode had me intrigued and hooked! I love the sentiment in this drama. And I am a firm believer in Carpe Diem. The OST has that certain romantic vibe of the old times as well.
They live during very dangerous times a certain romantic vibe can be felt everywhere. It's nostalgic. During that Joseon era, every slice of happiness is like a gift. I could feel the atmosphere during the Joseon Youth Alliance movement. Is it because both of our male leads have that certain old aura in them? Both are perfect for this drama. I came to know Yoo In Ah when he guested in the variety show, I Live Alone. His personality is a bit the same as the introvert aspect of his personality as a writer. Writing with his abs and selling his books with his looks.
Every aspect of this drama is near to perfection. The production team even took a particular detail in terms of fashion and style of all characters. Even the interior design of their houses was spot on. The only downside is how they portray a ghost could be. When he turned into a dog and went to the shop of the female lead. When he transformed into a human, the dog can no longer be seen. I thought he could only possess animals not completely transform into one. The dog should still be there and Ha IN should still be holding its leash. Bloopers or simply overlooked?
Nevertheless, I get and understand now why this drama reaped several awards. It is deserving of the awards. And this drama deserves a nine rating in MDL.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This is such a beautiful story of a friendship and love so strong that it transcends even time. Even almost a month after finishing it, I still think about it. It's one of those rare stories that stay with you. It starts with a writer who is having trouble writing his next book, but keeps remembering snippets of his past life. A ghost comes into his life then, and helps him on his journey to remembering. The ghost also brings Seol back into his life. Slowly, over time, the three get closer and the deep friendship that they had in their past lives continues in the present.
The OST, the deep relationship between the three main characters, and the determination to free their country keeps you riveted. I felt every single one of their emotions throughout this. The acting is superb and raw. Definitely don't hesitate to watch this.
"Hwi Young prayed to the skies just before he died. He prayed and asked to be with Soo Hyun and Yool even in his next life. The skies answered his prayer."
Was this review helpful to you?
I loved it!
If there were flaws, and I know there are plenty of flaws to this series... I did not notice them because that's how the story successfully distracted me from it. Usually, I get irritated with inaccuracies or get bothered by some other minor things in Asian shows that gets minus points. What ever magic this Korean Drama had, I fell in love with this story.The music was great, it did not feel like they were over used. Enjoyed it each time it came up to make the scene impressionable.
The actors and actresses were amazing, even the side characters and dislikable ones as well. At first I did not like Go Kyung Pyo, maybe it was his face. Maybe he was just too nice to be realistic. The actor really pulled through with his acting talents, which impressed me and I change my mind. Thank you, sir for proving me wrong to judge you that way.
The story... oufff the story is unique and does not suffer from Cinderella syndrome (THANK GOD)! It is serious, which makes the story amazing. It is comedic, which makes the story not too overwhelmingly heavy. It is CUTE! many moments where I wanted to hug the characters, and I don't mean the main characters or because they are good looking/hot. This story will pull at the heart strings. Used quite a few tissues, but that's just me being an overly sensitive baby :)
Give this series a chance and enjoy.
Was this review helpful to you?
You would never forget it.
okay honestly I was debating on whether to give 8.5 or 9 for the rating but decided on 9 because of how hot ML is. I mean just the glasses get the .5 rating. I love the hairstyle and the suits.( I am talking of their past lives not present. )The storyline is amazing and really one of a kind BUT, it could have been portrayed better. Something fell clumsy and unordered while watching the whole thing. I just bing watched the whole thing in 1 and half days. The script and story was good but the way in which it was told was kinda flat. And I personally felt there could have been more past life scenes.
Casting/acting/music idc everything was just top-notch. And that just one kiss scene (iykyk).
As someone who loved Mr Sunshine and hoped for the same here(I know nothing could be that level), Chicago typewriter didn't actually meet my expectations. I had hopes for this one, but yea couldn't meet the bar set by Mr Sunshine I guess.
Without comparing or just pulling off any expectations I would have loved it. Chicago typewriter has its own charms and characters I'll always keep in my heart. Just the thing that it felt slow in their present lives and I just wanted to see their whole past life. I guess that's what made this drama a bit draggy for me.
Apart from all of that, I think everyone should watch it and decide if it's worth their time or not. It's captivating to pull you enough and make you watch the whole thing.
Was this review helpful to you?
