Story:
For me this detective story was surprising and entertaining. It was something completely new and different. The way how past and present evens were connected only by an old walky-talky was brilliant. Story has many questions left to answer and is kept for the audience to decipher on what they want to happen is very intriguing. The ending was unexpected but expected at the same time. I am satisfied with the ending.
Acting/ Cast/Characters:
At first in my eyes Kentaro Sakaguchi was that actor whom I can’t imagine playing dark themed dramas or movies but this drama proved me wrong. The way how he deals and delivers his character emotions and thoughts was amazing.
Also Kichise Michiko, in my eyes, did a very good job showing her characters soft side while still being this strong independent woman who has sealed her heart from the outside world.
The chemistry between characters was good too. I liked how Saegusa Kento and Sakurai Misaki coming into each others lives did show trust build up towards each other and some character development. But I did see some lack in character build up but I couldn’t wrap my finger around it.
Music:
For opening and ending scene is used BTS – Don’t Let Go. Starting this drama, I thought that songs part was chosen weirdly or randomly even. But as I continued the drama, I got used to it and at one point I caught myself thinking that the part of the song might be chosen for a reason.
Notes
I hope we will be able see more of these type of dramas/ movies from Kentaro.
Was this review helpful to you?
If you're into Erased/Boku dake ga Inai Machi (manga, anime, movie or drama), this one is right up your alley. It has the same elements of detective/mystery storyline, a time travel element and the very first case of this drama is similar to the main one in Erased. This story, though, is less focused on one specific character and has various ones whose choices and lives impact the main arc, so it's more fast paced and has more puzzle pieces to gather. I appreciated that a lot.
The cases depicted in the drama are influenced often by real ones, and most of them are very graphic in terms of what they depict, so keep that in mind if you're impressionable. Still, I think they're handled pretty well and showcase the complexity of each one while making them fit on the overall story.
The time travel aspect is done via communication of the two leads, and stories of this kind tend to be tricky because of how they handle paradoxes and whatnot. I think this one uses the trope very well, it connects well throughout and keeps you on the edge of your seat, wondering what will happen next.
As a detective drama, it isn't primarily focused on who is or isn't guilty but on how law and justice don't always go hand in hand. This isn't an ideal portrayal where policemen are always good or where the justice system never fails, it's a story about shades of grey and how what's right isn't always what's fair. Considering the subject matter and the cases portrayed, the focus of the show was impeccable in that sense, and taking into account that there are TONS of detective/police jdramas out there, this perspective is much appreciated.
As it normally happens with jdramas, this version is shorter than its kdrama counterpart. Still, I think the length of this is perfect as it is, it would have dragged too much for my liking in a longer format. There seems to be a Special Episode that apparently is linked to this drama though, I haven't found info on it, so I'm gonna assume it's a side story which doesn't add to the main one in any determining factor, but who knows.
All in all, I highly recommend this drama to those who are fans of the thriller genre, like detective stories that aren't always black and white, enjoy time travel elements and want a story to keep them hooked.
Was this review helpful to you?
Story: The story was as awesome as the kdrama, except much faster paced. The suspense is there as well. However, I would have preferred if they changed the cases to different cases then the original 2015 kdrama (at least a little bit - all they did was reduce the amount of cases for time).
Cast: I think the cast was well thought out, however the main lead seemed a little out of place for me (my opinion).
Overall I do recommend it to everyone including the people that saw the 2015 kdrama version.
Sorry if this comes off as a bad review, but I had mixed feelings from this drama.
Was this review helpful to you?
I found this movie when I search for related movie or dorama with Signal. Since this is a movie, I decided to download it. I just watch it today and it turns out to be a heartwarming movie (^_^) The conflict of the lead role quite complicated tho, but the settlement is smooth and sweet. How the role care to each other is sweet and heartwarming. The pace is a little bit slow in the beginning, but not that slow so makes you bored. The way they show us how to projecting a movie is interesting. Oh! And the ending song (Mirai by Kylee) is nice to hear (^_^) In the end, this movie makes my day and bring smile to me (^_^)
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Don't waste your time and watch the Korean version instead.
So... I've watched this drama when it came out in 2018 but I decided to rewatch the Korean version that I absolutely love on Netflix and, because a special episode from the Japanese version (that I didn't know of) came out quite recently, I decided to rewatch this version as well before watching this special episode. I remembered not liking this version very much and here is why.Let's start with the story which is the most important part of why I dislike this version. The Korean version is perfect, well written, the story flows really well throughout the episodes and I understand that the Japanese version had to make some choices in term of changes (not to be just a copy paste of the Korean version - even though it is quite a bit) and in term of plot lines to keep as they have only 10 episodes of 45 minutes each. Some choices were pretty good: they didn't keep the second serial murders case in which Soo Hyun was kidnapped, Iwata learns about the walkie talkie and Oyama by eavesdropping one of the transmissions and Saegusa's mother protects him from his brother's case's mess by giving him to relatives... Other than that, from the very first episode, this version is a mess.
The very first mistake they made was to change the timeline. Right from the start, the story begins in 1995 with the kidnapping case. But Oyama only discovers the corpse of the main suspect 5 years later! Also, Oyama didn't have the walkie talkie in 1995 and started having the transmissions in 1997, which is ridiculous! In the Korean version, the story starts with the same case but the case begins in 2000, the same year Jae Han finds the corpse and he already has the walkie talkie and knows about the transmissions since 1989! These errors lead to two inconsistencies. First, why is Oyama still in possession of a walkie talkie in 1997 when they already had mobile phones and were even seen communicated this way in the drama? At least, the Korean version is logical as in 1989, mobile phones didn't exist and it was their only way of communicating. Second, like the Korean version, the cold case squad was created right after solving the kidnapping case with the help of the transmissions. However, for an unknown reason, in the Japanese version, the transmission first starts in 2010 for Saegusa and the cold case squad is created the same year. And then, 8 years pass, the cold case squad is still in service and Saegusa just joins the team. Again, this is highly illogical as the cold case squad is wanted to be got rid of as soon as possible by the higher-ups and the main villain of this drama especially. How did the squad manage to exist for 8 long years? That would mean that they were successful solving cold cases which doesn't seem like it when we see them again in 2018...
There is another inconsistency created because of this timeline change. Saegusa is seen lonely and kind of depressed at school. This was because in the Korean version, Hae Young lost his older brother and couldn't see his mother because his father took him with him after the gang rape case that involved his brother. But in the Japanese version, there are no reasons at all for him to be sad and lonely because the gang rape case hasn't happened yet and he's still living with his mother and brother who is very much alive. So why doesn't he have any friends at school? I mean, he should at least have one or two friends!
Also, the Japanese version is way too rushed that they forget very important elements that explain the characters' actions. For example, in the first serial murder case, Jae Han suspects the bus driver of being the murderer because he saw him on the crime scene and he indicated him the wrong direction. In the Japanese version, there's no reason for him to suspect the bus driver apart from lying in his testimony as he was not on the crime scene. Moreover, they don't develop the characters' relationships enough. Oyama and Sakurai barely interact with each other (so how is it possible that they fall in love? She doesn't even confess her feelings so what Oyama said after leaving her is inconsistent - again!). Oyama barely interacts with his colleagues as well so there is no team spirit built in this drama and I wonder how he could have back up to save him at the very end. And because they put Iwata as Oyama's chief instead of Nakamoto (who seem to have the same position throughout the years instead of climbing up like in the Korean version - but it's true that only 5 years pass in the Japanese version instead of 11 years in the Korean version), they messed up the relationships between the three characters - especially between Oyama and Nakamoto.
Anyway... There are other inconsistencies in this drama - like the fact that the police have Saegusa's phone when he escaped from them at the hospital (how did they get it?...) and that the cold case squad still exist after what happens with Oyama and the fact that it is not possible because the kidnapping case has been solved in 2000, not 2010... - but I'm going to stop here and talk about another thing that I didn't like in this version... The acting.
It really depends on the drama but I usually don't have any problem whatsoever with Japanese acting. There are some great dramas out there in which the actors are phenomenal. But it is not the case in this drama, sorry... I liked some of the actors like Watabe Atsuro (Nakano), Komoto Masahiro (Iwata) or Kitamura Kazuki (Oyama) for the most part but the Japanese actors in this drama were too much at expressing their emotions. They were always yelling for no reasons and expressing despair, sadness with grand gestures that really didn't fit the situation. Especially in the first episode, during the interrogation of the woman (who is supposed to act in a very cold blooded way), we could clearly see when she was panicking and it was clear from the start that she was guilty. While in the Korean version, the woman barely moves and is only fidgeting to show her panicky state.
About the music, there's nothing much to say apart that the song of BTS really helped the series being known. At least, I like the opening better than the Korean one. They sometimes misused the soundtrack but it is only noticeable in one scene around the end of the drama.
Would I recommend this drama? Absolutely not. Watch the Korean version instead, it is way better in everything.
The Japanese version could have probably been better if they changed the cases they are working on and chose Japanese cold cases instead.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Signal The japanese version
So I knew about this drama or about the Korean version when it's first released and I think there was a huge fuss about it at that time , I didn't watch it yet but I guess It will be on my list to watch , I really liked the Japanese version there was so much things going on and of course I just binged watched it all and I really like it , it was drama about cold cases, each case has something to do with the past or somehow it has beginning in the past that needed help from the detective (one of the main characters in the series) of course other characters were good too , I didn't get bored at all , I was so excited to continue watching the next episode to know what will happen , it was a really good drama , even though it didn't have any good ending but I think it was a satisfying ending more than the one in the movie,but the whole drama is very good .and I loved how everything were going fast.
Was this review helpful to you?
