I watched a bit of Kamenashi Kazuya and Ueno Juri and he did make him more playful but his appearance doesn't really match the Kindaichi description.
Anyway, this is the only Kindaichi that I watched that is not the original and I watched it the whole way through. I am very impressed with Yamada Ryosuke and Kawaguchi Haruna but especially Yamada Ryosuke since he reminds me so much of Domoto Tsuyoshi in terms of acting Kindaichi (he really did his homework and must have watched it a few times himeself) Apart from looking a little bit chubbier his voice sounds like him. Kawaguchi Haruna also did a good job.
The story is your usual Kindaichi which usually (well I usually) do not know the killer until towards the end plus it is modernised.
I definitely recommend this to the Kindaichi fans.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
to tell you the truth the only reason i watched this was because of wu chun and seungri ^_^
i gave the story a 9 because it was little confusing to me but over all it was really good
i gave acting/cast 10 because i loved who they picked thought that each were good for there parts
and plus i thought that they did acted well ^_^
if you like mystery's totally watch this OR IF YOU JUST WANT TO WATCH THIS BECAUSE YOUR FAV STAR IS IN IT ^_^
ooh yah i didn't every much get that it was a japanese drama and it was in hong kong but doesn't really matter
so basically I THINK THAT THIS IS GOOD ^_^
Was this review helpful to you?
Yamada's acting was very similar to his other characters (like in Hidarime Tantei Eye) and I couldn't see an unique Kindaichi at all. And Arioka Daiki was just an eye candy, I wished he would do more in the story. Kawaguchi Haruna was....well, she played 2 characters and we couldn't see any difference either.
For me, this was a big fail and I can't give this more than 4 point overall.
Was this review helpful to you?
Where is the expressions? where is the proper voice manipulations? Kawaguchi Haruna who was supposed to be the strongest acting wise, was the weakest. Then yamada...i really don't think he gave a new dimension to this role and did not even completely catch "kindaichi". Wu chun... well ...obviously -.- i am not a fan of his acting since i think he needs to work on it more and in this one , indeed it was bad. I think the only one who did a good job was kiritani kenta. sungri had a small role but he was bad at it. almost as bad as kawaguchi.
the music was nice , , nothing great .
Lastly, I would like to talk about the predictability of this. I dunno if others found it easy to spot the murderer but it was somewhat obvious that it was not one of the three brothers.
as far as rewatching goes, i do not think that it will be the same as the first time and things will become boring.
Was this review helpful to you?