This review may contain spoilers
I'm so confused by the hate of this. I think a lot of it was to mislead us. We are getting a tiny glimpse of their separation.. more can be at play. The baby is HIGHLY unlikely to be Shi De... he wasn't in America long enough to knock someone up. I think the most logical theory is that the girl is his step sister (he did go to America for his mother's wedding) and the baby can be either her's (with another man) or even Shi De's half brother. Shi De probably decided to stay in America to help his family... those medical bills could be for his step father (basing it off the name on it.. makes most sense to me).I think this special episode was just to MAKE us speculate and going crazy with theories until March 5th. I think the major anger is going to be that Shi De stayed in America for 2 years instead of the promised 2 months... Shu Yi was pretty upset at the thought of a long distance relationship in the last episode so maybe him jumping to conclusions and then finding out Shi De wasn't coming back created more of a problem.
The screenwriter wrote the majority of the HIStory series, so I'm going to give her the benefit of the doubt.. that series is amazing.
Was this review helpful to you?
This is a mess and most likely a disappointment to many. Nothing was shown or explained clearly. It's only a "spinoff", 10 minutes long, that felt more like some kind of longer music video. I still hope s2 will answer all our questions. That said, this spinoff was beautifully filmed. The backgrounds, the colors, the places, the music were great. The acting was perfect too. Especially when there wasn't much story they had to act out. They just put some scenes together in such a random way that's hard to even form an opinion about the whole thing. Shu Yi's behavior felt out of character, which I'm not a fan of. But we don't know the whole background, so hopefully at the end of s2 all those puzzle pieces will come together and make sense.
EDIT: those puzzle pieces made not much sense. Very lazy writing.
Was this review helpful to you?
It's like a teaser for the second season
I don’t fully understand what exactly is going on in Gao She De’s life in America, but it seems like he has his hands full. I feel like we get a lot of different hints as to what might be going on for him to stay there for much longer than planned. But we don’t get any definite answers. It’s almost like a teaser for the second season of the series with a few glances into the lives of Zhou Shu Yi and Gao Shi De during their separation. I am a bit disappointed by the fact that a simple misunderstanding and lack of communication seem to be the main conflict both for the special and as a set up for season 2.It's very confusing though and not a lot of it makes sense. It was definitely not was I expected from the special episode. What happened to special episodes being sweet? And cute?
Was this review helpful to you?
Another grest bl drama
Ep6. 5. gave some background info leading up to part2. The 5 year misunderstandingthen???? Starting at the age of 10 Gao shi de meets Zhao shy yi while he was crying on the steps over his dad abandoned when a boy gives him a tissue and tells him it will be alright he has his mom when someone calls him he runs yelling his name. They meet again and shy yi doesn't remember him so he works hard to be #1 and shy yi always in. 2nd place. So now attending college shy yi figures he won't see Gao shi de and be 1st again. Until the day shi de makes shy yi his page boy(thru a video blackmail) and does everything to make him forgot his angry and become shi de friend, but shi de limes him and whispered in his ear thinking he was asleep. After that shi de started to hide from shy yi due to his heart is in alot of pain, but shy yi is mad since he can't find him over a week until he finally finds him.. these 6 episode tells the story of how commitment and persistent can payoff in the name of love.Ep6. 5.gave some background info leading up to the 5 year misunderstanding.
Was this review helpful to you?
Short and messes with your head
This special completely messes with ones head, I am very happy that the next season is out or I would probably have strangled someone for what these 10 minutes did with this show, yet I still rated it the same as the previous, why you ask? well because I felt like it and because it really did make me want to see the next season ASAP. So definitely worth watching seeing that season 1 was sweet and left me wanting more, this little teaser managed to upset me and want it fixed... So I guess if you liked season one you will want to watch this too.Was this review helpful to you?
10 minutes of misunderstanding to create the drama for Season 2
This special episode follow the season 1 of "We Best Love: No. 1 For You" and is clearly there to create the dramatic arc in the relationship of the couple and to make the bridge with the season 2 of the series. The conflict is all based on misunderstanding and communication issues, which could be frustrating for some viewers. I was not too upset by that because I'm in a hurry to watch season 2 and curious to see the resolution.The actors do what they can with the script they are given. It is clearly not an easy job to sell this huge shift in the dynamic of the relationship in the short span of 10 minutes.
I would recommend this to people that have seen the season 1 of course, before watching season 2. If you have watched the Special version of Season 1, it seems it is not necessary to watch this SP.
Was this review helpful to you?
Great chemistry, odd pace
Review is for WBL Special Edition: I wish so much that this drama was longer because the pace was way too fast and all I kept thinking was that I loved the chemistry and I loved the main leads together and wanted the development of enemies-to-lovers to be more slow. I probably could've done without the side characters getting so much screentime, and even more without the string of misunderstandings at the end (even though I know the drama is setting up a season 2). The chemistry is great, the OST is catchy, the acting is pretty good, and the dialogue is beautiful — sometimes it's just a little confusing how the characters got to where they were because we didn't have time to show the "in-between" moments.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
upcoming plot
Although in this episode they don’t have a happy ending, it’s leading to the plot for season 2 to bring tension between them. So watching this episode would give you background info into season 2 but it wouldn’t necessarily be a need to watch this episode because it would most likely give background in the beginning on season 2.Although in this episode they don’t have a happy ending, it’s leading to the plot for season 2 to bring tension between them. So watching this episode would give you background info into season 2 but it wouldn’t necessarily be a need to watch this episode because it would most likely give background in the beginning on season 2.
Although in this episode they don’t have a happy ending, it’s leading to the plot for season 2 to bring tension between them. So watching this episode would give you background info into season 2 but it wouldn’t necessarily be a need to watch this episode because it would most likely give background in the beginning on season 2.
Although in this episode they don’t have a happy ending, it’s leading to the plot for season 2 to bring tension between them. So watching this episode would give you background info into season 2 but it wouldn’t necessarily be a need to watch this episode because it would most likely give background in the beginning on season 2.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Spin off court et ambigu
Au niveau de l'alchimie entre les protagonistes principaux, personne ne peut douter de l'excellence ou le talent des acteurs. Par contre, L'épisode spin-off était tellement court, tellement ambigu qu'on ne comprend pas le problème déclencheur de l'embrouille ni la séparation entre "Shi de" et "Shu Yi"."Shi de" est resté Pendant deux ans aux usa au lieu des deux mois convenus, et pourtant on ne montre que le contacte est au point mort entre les deux amants sans explications valables puis on saute à une fin injustifiée, lorsque "Shu Yi" par amour à "Shi de" voyage aux usa pour le voir, mais tombe sur lui en plein pique-nique avec une femme et un bébé dans les bras, rapidement il saute à la conclusion de la tromperie et se donne raison pour couper sa relation avec "Shi de" et ainsi prolonger la séparation à deux ans. sans prendre en considération d'autres théories liées au nouveau statut familial de "Shi de" où même le confronter pour avoir des explications.
Pour moi, la réaction n'était pas logique, ni le temps que "Shi de'' a passé aux usa ne lui permet d'entamer une relation qui engendre un bébé, mais connaissant la complexité de personnage de "Shu Yi" son arrogance et sa fierté, j'ai toléré amèrement un peu, cette situation illogique, cela dit c'est impossible pour moi de tolérer l'ambiguïté de récit, venant d'une scénariste a renommé national comme "Lin Pei yu" la marraine des sagas BL "HISTORY".
Je pense plutôt qu'elle voulait induire les téléspectateurs en erreur avec ce spin off afin d'assoiffer le public pour la prochaine saison, malheureusement je trouve qu'ils ont utilisé le temps donné d'une manière inefficace, 10 minutes sont largement suffisantes pour créer une intrigue passionnante à donné des frissons, au lieu de cet épisode spécial très mal structuré et ou la relation à distance n'était pas mise en valeur comme il le faut.
Was this review helpful to you?
