This review may contain spoilers
loved this much better than the original
I was super excited to see that there was going to be a remake of Cherry Magic, because unfortunately the original didn't really live up to the hype for me. I hoped that this remake would fix at least some of my issues with the original, and thankfully, it did!I absolutely love the additions and changes made to the story. The last few episodes especially were so, so sweet--and truly indicate how much this show, and this couple of Karan and Achi, care about communication. The main couple are so tender and kind with each other; their many hugs and moments of hand-holding were genuinely nice to see. Of course I'm glad they kissed as well (one way they deviated from the Japanese LA), but the way they clung to each other was one of my favorite aspects of their relationship. My only complaint I suppose is that sometimes Achi felt a bit too stiff; I couldn't always feel the same level of care and emotion in him that I felt in Karan.
For the second ship, well. I hated Tsuge lmao so I was very pleasantly surprised that Jinta was one of my favorite characters! While I did like Jinta and Min together a lot, I feel like Jinta really shone. He had a lot of character growth and was consistently really funny, really crazy, and a pretty good friend and boyfriend. I was really happy for Min by the end, they seem like a great couple who actually have something to bond over and it was fun to see!
And finally, for Rock and Pai. While their relationship was really cute, I honestly wish it would have stayed just a friendship. However, what we did get with them was adorable so I'm not too mad. I really enjoyed how it seemed like they truly got along well and made each other happy.
Fuck Tanaka though, terrible boss.
Anyway, this show was super fun and sweet, I would definitely suggest giving it a try!
Was this review helpful to you?
Without any expectation I liked it, I really do. I wished they released this series Globally
I've watched the Japan adaptation first so when I find out GMM going to make a remake honestly, I'm kinda worried. I'm I actually loved the japan adaptation even there was no much skinship or even kissing. So I tried to watch this and its turn out that... I LIKED THAI VERSION much than the japan version. Sorry I had to say this because I usually never put Thai BL into my top list. I guess this may kinda biased or reference. So here's why- The Story : The Story is still enjoyable, I'm mean I'm glad they didn't change much storyline between two male leads. But I have to say the last 2 episodes was like fast paced(?) I know theres not much drama going on around that ep but it feels so rushed. But I still liked it tho and also theres no actuall villain in this story and just about Karan & Achi fighting for their love together makes it even more better IMO.
- Cast : Everyone did great but Hands down to Tawan/Karan he definetly carried the whole series, IDK his acting is just geunine especially when he is crying his heart out it was so real It makes me fall into him deeper.
- Music/Scoring : I personally think they use very good scoring in the very important scene, it just click and gosh it make the scene even more better than I expect, it was really beautiful scoring. Who ever incharge for that he deserve a raise.
I feel like this should be released globally this has huge potential much people should watch this, I really wish gmm would released this globally in the short time. If they did I'm definetly going to rewatch it all over again, I love to ride this series more than once đđđđ
Was this review helpful to you?
so freaking adorable
there is something to be said about just a cute, sweet, romantic series without much angst.I loved Cherry Magic Japan I donât think a series has never made me laugh as hard as that did so I was hesitant about the Thai version. but here is the thing they are completely different. yes the premise is the same, but the Thai version has so much depth in it.
it was the slowest of slow burns but dang was it good. this is probably my favorite TayNew series now.
also Karan is the greenest of green flags.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Taynew comeback
The story was amazing and the acting was making it more amazing because it is Taynew, making the whole series questiong are they Karan and Achi or Tay and New. The proposing was making me tear because it is show that it doesnât have to be the top propose to the bottom because when you have love, it does not matter. What unexpectingly was the tear of Achi (New) was not in the plot, which make it more emotional and a new level of acting.Was this review helpful to you?
Cute and Sweet Pairs
It is a heartwarming and beautiful depiction of how both Achi and Karan fall for each other because of their kindness. There is a warmth to the storyâs well-placed humor. And a sincerity in the way it has begun to tell each characterâs story. Newwiee is adorable as the fluffy Achi, who despite being a hard-working employee has low self-esteem issues. Tawan is equally good as the dashing Karan, with a blinding smile that has all the office girls weak in their knees. Most of the story unfolds in an office set-up, which was a refreshing change from all the college fluff such series are filled with.Was this review helpful to you?
P*RN WITHOUT ANY PLOT AND WITHOUT ANY FEELINGS OF LOVE
Thai ruined another great Japanese BL after Love Stage.Those liking this trash are only obsessed stalker fans of those u*gly actors. All fans are happy that Japan intervened legally, now only waiting for this to be cancelled forever. And the actors can end in disgrace to ruin it.
U*ly actors that can't act at all, 0 chemistry, and only sly perverted kisses.
Karan is an obsessed stalker who wants to r*pe Achi, withou any fanboy love feelings from the original.
Achi is a party boy, without any antisocial skills from the original.
People are too blatant and ridiculous that can't even understand the difference between being antisocial and being shy.
second pair is so stupid i can't, without feelings from the original.
And those stupid perverted inserted touchy thing, totally unnecessary.
They say it's an adaptation of the manga, but they should explain why they cut half of the manga, without adapting it.
As always, Thai are too p*rn and too touchy to be able to adapt more delicate and pure BL like that. They have the flavor of lust and s*x, not the flavor of love.
I don't recommend this trashy thing to anyone, and i'm happy that every Japanese BL fans raised in protest.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Cute and funny watch just not didnât meet my expectations
Cute and funny, a lot of fluff and 0 drama. But I personally couldnât enjoy it as much because I kept comparing it the Japanese version (Cherry Maho) So even though itâs very different I will say some of the differences I noticed for those who want to know.1. Characters
So first obviously we have to talk about the big change in personality of the characters, now of course not all had a big change but some of them did.
âąKurosawa-Karan
Karan is overall, a more expressive character mostly since we got to hear his crazy thoughts which clashed with his cool personality but I also feel we didnât get to know the real Karan not the mind Karan. Also I felt that Karan wasnât as much of a green flag, as much as people like to think, Karan was jealous but jealous really jealous and since he is more expressive it came across as invasive, Karan also was pretty obsessed with Achi by waiting outside his house and all, then him going to visit that much when Achi was working made the then climax of Achi loosing his powers loose the build up and longing
âąAdachi-Achi
Achi generally just really didnât struggle as much as Adachi did, If he ever really was which made me feel like he couldâve gotten with Karan even without the powers, also since the problems got solved very quickly which thanks to that we got less angst and drama but it also took a big part of the depth of the show.
âąSide Couple(s)
The Thai version did a better job developing the side characters and their relationships considering they had more time to give them; like Jinta Min which was alright but at least 10 times better than the JP ver. I personally didnât like the RockJoi pairing though it was just kinda not interesting and had too much screen time for my taste but considering the long time they had, it was kinda necessary
2. Main relationship progression
Weirdly even though this drama is longer it felt like things were going too quickly, KaranAchis relationship was very fast I didnât feel like there was enough progression and time, which just made it feel fake, and as much as I like TayNews interactions and interviews (I have seen many) I donât know if I felt like they were a believable relationship, and it definitely has a lot to do with the story and the pacing I mentioned before
Conclusion:
So even though I personally prefer the JP version I also feel this one is pretty different and overall not bad I would recommend it
Was this review helpful to you?
boa versĂŁo
a primeira vez que eu vi o anĂșncio sobre o remake de cherry magic eu odiei, nĂŁo fazia sentido nenhum pra mim um remake de uma obra que era relativamente recente. por este motivo, nĂŁo acompanhei a sĂ©rie conforme foi saindo semanalmente, e lembro que ao tentar ver o primeiro episĂłdio eu achei algo legal mas nada mais, entĂŁo, nĂŁo continuei a sĂ©rie. apĂłs ver muitas pessoas elogiando eu decidi dĂĄ uma nova chance e valeu a pena.Ă© complicado nĂŁo fazer uma comparação entre as versĂ”es existentes mas honestamente eu acho que ambas tem seus pontos fortes e valem a pena serem assistidas. o casal principal Ă© perfeito em ambas as versĂ”es, impossĂvel nĂŁo vibrar com eles. sobre os personagens secundĂĄrios o da versĂŁo thai me agradou muito mais, sĂŁo personagens mais divertidos e tem uma histĂłria mais interessante, o casal secundĂĄrio me vez vibrar mais com eles (apesar de ter ficado decepcionado com o "apagamento" deles no final de sĂ©rie) de um modo geral eu recomendaria a versĂŁo japonesa primeiro, ela tem uma duração muito menor e conta muito bem a histĂłria, mas tambĂ©m recomendaria a versĂŁo thai pois ela conseguiu ser um bom remake.
Was this review helpful to you?
Cherry magic TH is comfort!
So cherry magic TH is the first BL series I decided to watch after my long break from BLs. One day I just came across the poster and thought why not give it a chance and I am proud of my decision since then. I just loved the story like how it was simple and just completely magic. The positivity brings you comfort and it feels like to just go back again and again to watch it.TayNew are the best. I am happy that they were the chosen ones to play the character of achi and karan and they just served the best chemistry. The actors they are... It is commendable. The emotions were getting reflected through their eyes. And after knowing that their real personalities are way too different from their characters, it is more fascinating to watch.
The series will make u happy, complete and fulfilled. If you are going through sadness, heartbreak and need that energy just watch it and it will make your heart light.
Was this review helpful to you?
Pure Escapist Sweetness
I don't usually write reviews but I also don't usually rewatch dramas either and I rewatched this entire drama right after finishing it the first time. First, the negatives (they are very minor): Some weird edits/cuts, music was mediocre and the secondary couples didn't hold my interest at all. But the positives! Wow! The chemistry between the leads was amazing (I did some research afterwards and can see that they have acted as a couple several times before). Maybe that is why they seemed so comfortable with each other. I found myself squeeing even from the hugs and eye contact. The snogging was next level even though there really wasn't enough of it for my taste. The romance is soft and sweet and the overall 'feel' of it was like having a cozy blanket thrown over you on a rainy day. Also, there were nice, kind and strong female characters (no annoying female antagonist which is way too common in BL dramas). I highly recommend watching this (and rewatching). I will be looking for more dramas featuring these two leads.Was this review helpful to you?
Best watched without seeing the original
The is a decent, enjoyable BL from GMMTV - not a stand out but far from the worst.The years that Tay and New have been working together and their friendship shows in the natural chemistry and New gets plenty chances to use his trademark confused/shocked expression!
Where it falls down is when comared to the Japanese original with the comdey seeming more forced than natural. . Ok this is an extended version with more of the story covered but much in the same way that happens when there are american remakes of european series/movies it's ended up being more polished and slick (I'm deseprately trying to avoid saying bland which would be a little too harsh) which causes it t lose character.
Was this review helpful to you?
1,000 out of 10--the best BL ever.
Where do I even start? This show blew every other BL out of the water and that's saying a lot as I'm a huuuuge BL fan.The acting and cast were amazing. Every single actor but especially the leads.
It managed to be really captivating and suspenseful, yet there was no painfully drawn-out conflict. Everything was dealt with in such a healthy and wholesome way.
Funny and fluffy but also really touching and deep in parts.
The kisses. !!!!!!!
It's hard to even put into words. This was the most magical show I've ever seen. 1,000 out of 10!
Was this review helpful to you?