i forgive mary stayed out all night.
it's most glaring flaw for me is the complete personality change in Kang Moo Gyul. i get that love changes people, but he loves Mae-Ri for a while before he turns into a different person, and it happens in the space of a single kiss. befoere the kiss he's all cool and reserved, then after the kiss he's all kitties and bunnies rainbows and cute, but i dont think i could breath with a BF like that.
then of course there is the totally over wrought and non-sensical ways they chose to move the plot forward (when it doesnt stall for 2 episodes at a time) i mentioned this in another post. there is heavy use of the idiot plot device in MSOAN. i mean, seriously KMG cant just lock the freakin door? there are misunderstandings a pleanty but no one ever explains themselves, the only explination is that it's a cheap easy way to create conflict, and do the writers really expect anyone to believe that any female chose Kang Moo Gyul over Jung In?
Why do i forgive MSOAN?
1st, the cast. Jang Guen Suk and Kim Jae Wook are both so hot in this and even though wardrobe made Moon Guem.. what ever her name is look like a 14 yo bag lady she is very endearing. KJW actually brings a depth to his role that the other characters seem to lack. JGS in this is very nostalgic for me. i've dated a couple of Kang Moo Gyuls in my time and JGS did a good job with the flawed character development he was handed.
2nd. i find it REALLY funny. i dont often LOL in actuality. usually the most you get out of me is a closed mouth chuckle, but there were several moment in this show where i just cackled like hyena on meth.