I've only seen 4 of these dramas at the moment -_- But they're all on my list to watch haha. Considering I've only been watching dramas for about 2 months now I haven't gotten around to seeing them all. I'm in the process of watching Meteor Garden right now, since I saw Hana Yori Dango (fell in love with it haha) and watched BBF (wasn't as impressed). I do think the dramas that were picked were picked out of their popularity
I have watched only one in the JDrama category and I wasn't crazy about the ending

I have watched 4/5 in the Korean category and 2 in the Taiwanese one.

I think Secret Garden should have been higher up on the Korean list as Fated to Love You should have been #1 in the Taiwanese one. I love Mike He, but he was really the one reason I watched Devil Beside You.
i have only watched

2 3 4 in j list

and i agree with Jeanie ... 3 and 4 was the best kdramas :) i am surprised at full house making this list...
Zombierella wrote: I have seen all except for one: The Magicians of Love. I wanna rant as to why most of them are in the list and what are the voters thinking (I mean, it's Top Dramas of All Time for god's sake!) but I should know better. Polls such as this tend to be a popularity game. And I for one am guilty.
- I'm surprised that Nobuta one-upped HYD. Don’t get me wrong, I love Nobuta. It’s simply beautiful and intricate – they deserve being there. But HYD, aren’t they more popular? They even have a movie. I though it’d be first. Hmm., never thought Yamapi and Kame has such influence. ^^
-Kdramas. Ha, why am I not surprised?
-Eh? Devil Beside You #1? I was thinking it would be Fated to Love You. Why, they even hold the highest average single-eps rating and even made a second instalment. :O Mike He sure has many fans.


Please rant! hehehe

Also, I'm happy Nobuta beat out HYD too. I never made it passed the first two seasons. I got bored about halfway through the first season, but had to keep watching to see how it ended. Then I figured the second season had to be good if they subsequently made a movie, but the story line was very uninspired. I was so annoyed by the end of season two, I couldn't even make it to the movie, lol.
TOP 5 JAPANESE DRAMAS

#1 Hanazakari no Kimitachi e
#2 Gokusen
#3 Nobuta wo Produce
#4 Hana Yori Dango
#5 One Litre of Tears
-----
seen all those. Imo they should be like this:
#1 HanaDan
#2 Gokusen
#3 One litre of tears
#4 Hana Kimi
#5 Nobuta

TOP 5 KOREAN DRAMAS

#1 You're Beautiful
#2 Boys Over Flowers
#3 Secret Garden
#4 Coffee Prince
#5 Full House
-----
seen all those (well haven't finished Full House Yet) and imo BOF should be #4 while Coffee Prince should be #2

TOP 5 CHINESE (TAIWANESE) DRAMAS

#1 Devil Beside You
#2 Autumn Concerto
#3 Meteor Garden
#4 The Magicians of Love
#5 Fated to Love You
----
Seen only DBY so I can't say anything D:
lipo wrote: TOP 5 JAPANESE DRAMAS

#1 Hanazakari no Kimitachi e
#2 Gokusen
#3 Nobuta wo Produce
#4 Hana Yori Dango
#5 One Litre of Tears


I've seen all of those. I agree that 1, 3 and 5 should be in the list but I didn't enjoy Gokusen in the slightest and although Hana Yori Dango is a good drama, there are A LOT better.

lipo wrote: TOP 5 KOREAN DRAMAS

#1 You're Beautiful
#2 Boys Over Flowers
#3 Secret Garden
#4 Coffee Prince
#5 Full House


I've seen all but Secret Garden which I'm currently watching.
Although good dramas I don't agree they're ~the best~ that there is. It's kind of like 'oo this has a pretty guy in it, I'll watch this'. Not that I've never done that but it's not what makes a drama good imo :/.
I think most of them are kind of average if you watch a lot of dramas. Saying that, I like all of them (although pretty bored with Secret Garden)

lipo wrote: TOP 5 CHINESE (TAIWANESE) DRAMAS

#1 Devil Beside You
#2 Autumn Concerto
#3 Meteor Garden
#4 The Magicians of Love
#5 Fated to Love You


I've only seen #1 of these XD. I've been meaning to watch #2 and #3 for a while.
I can't really comment on the rest of the list but I enjoyed Devil Beside You a lot.
I think Byakuyakou should've been in the list... or Kurosagi
lol i forgot i had posted my thoughts earlier... XD

fail me
xiian2 wrote: I think Byakuyakou should've been in the list... or Kurosagi


I love Kurosagi <3 (although it gets a bit repetitive after a while)