Since you like It's Okay That's Love, I'd recommend another Noh Hee-kyung (she's wrote the script for IOTL) drama--
Padam, Padam. It has fantasy/magical elements, but they're not exaggerated at all, and the drama has this realistic, down-to-earth vibe to it.
On the Way to the Airport is another good one, slow and low-key, but it deals with infidelity, which I understand is a big turn-off for some people.
And of course, there's
I Need Romance series (three of them, but each installment is completely unrelated to one another).