My theory if Eun Byul died...
She believed her twin sister should have lived in Seoul instead of her. Her guilt was probably really strong that causes her to hallucinate--> depression--> or even schizophrenic (the washroom episode where she screamed? and the weird paranormal activity around her? and all the hallucination she's been having?). She's cool on the outside but on the inside she's probably really sad/guilty/ depressed even though she has her friends, Yi Ahn, and her mother. THe reason was probably bcuz of Eun Bi. She wanted Eun Bi to live the same life as she is and Eun Byul wanted to escape from her life . She was probably really scared (aka haunting~)and wanted Eun Bi to take her place.
THere's actually a study of twins that one of the twins have a higher chance of schizophrenia. (studied in psychology)
My Questions:
1. why didn't they do DNA test right after they found the corpse?
Why the cremation pot only put the name Lee Eun Bi instead of Go Eun Byul?
2. OR maybe they believed Eun Bi is dead... but actually she is alive.
3. Or.. Eun Byul is actually dead in the first place (probably because she was kidnapped/murdered?) and her soul helped Eun Bi out of the water. (wait.. i dun think this makes sense...)
4. Even if both of them are alive... won't they fight for the same guy?? Yi ahn especially...
In the preview of ep 9, Yi Ahn was looking at the cremation pot of Lee Eun Bi not Eun Byul. Why was he sad when it's not Eun Byul's name on there? I know he is upset believing that Eun Byul is dead. But the hangeul (Korean letter)..is LEE EUN BI not GO EUN BYUL.
Maybe it was Eun Byul's cremation and they made a mistake with the name?
My theory if she is alive,
She must be hiding trying to look for the stalker... she is watching Eun Bi in the shadows. There's too much mysteries around Eun byul.
She is helping Eun bi by spreading the rumors. We still don't know much abt Eun Byul and Soo In.. but we do know Yi Ahn loved Eun Byul.