@Akki
Definitely agree with points 1, 2 and 4 but regarding the "Death Loop":
That's an interesting take on it. "Don't cross the boundary" is repeated many times in the drama, almost signifying that you've already lost control the moment you decided to get on that train. Think about it, "choosing" to get on the train in hopes of somehow taking revenge (in do won's case) but then again "choosing" to stay back for a loved one because of your own greed , these were all Do won's choices. He could have gone back after finding out that he is in the wrong place but because he wanted to stay even when a version of himself already existed in that world, it sent the wheels of fate (the train in this case) spinning to set things right. It means that though the choices initially may be ours, "fate" doesn't allow you to experience something and then have the control to change it. In your life, your choices determine your fate but when you try to change your choices for a better outcome, fate doesn't allow it. What seemed like "control" in your own experience is no longer your will/choice. Now fate is in complete control to set things straight. You might have chosen the first time but you don't get to rewrite something you don't like.
The people who crossed the line perhaps can't kill themselves and are instead transported to another world so that they can relive the "tragic" events again, always making them realise how wrong it was to "cross the line". Do won could have chosen to deal with the grief of seo kyung's death in his world and move on. But the moment he got on that train for "revenge" and then stayed back for wanting another chance with her, he basically sealed his own fate. Now, he will never get to move on because it is no longer his choice. Now, he will "have" to watch her die and then relive it in a different world over and over again as now, he cannot die either unless fate chooses to kill him.
WHAT AN AMAZING SHOW! A perfect execution of the concept and its consequences. I just love how much this show made me think about & analyse my own choices and I'm sure you will love it too. So please, WATCH IT!