The Story Of Pearl Girl - companion piece

 Fiona_HOD:

Wow so much information stated. Amazed with the work you had done for us viewers. Thank you.

 twinty:

Thank you so much for doing this! You are amazing. I appreciate you!

 BrightStar:

Thank you for this. Looking forward to it!

Thanks for liking!  We still have all the Sū Mùzhē episodes upcoming now in second half of this amazing drama, which is topping charts over LGIEF   :)  Enjoy the drama, and come back later to check latest infos! or add / correct anything I missed ;)

 Frost_edelweiss:

Thanks for liking!  We still have all the Sū Mùzhē episodes upcoming now in second half of this amazing drama, which is topping charts over LGIEF   :)  Enjoy the drama, and come back later to check latest infos! or add / correct anything I missed ;)

I am enjoying TSOPG so much! It is beautifully done. I am not surprised it ranked #1 on Vlinkage this week. 

 Frost_edelweiss:

come back later to check latest infos! or add / correct anything I missed ;)

I appreciate so much what you've done here that I've refrained to object anything in your historical exposition, but now that you've said "add or correct", I'll try to articulate my objections.

Premise: We know the setting is in Tang dynasty, but we have no idea of the exact year/era/rulership. It is important to know - if we want to evaluate how close and truthful is the drama setting to real history and real Silk Road route of the time - because the borders of Tang empire expanded and streched continuously.
1. I think the author(s) deliberately omitted this important data, partially because the political conflict of two princes is fictitious (that's why they can't tell who is the ruler of the moment) and partially because they invented Lánghuán (as you've correctly pointed out), but the reason why they invented such a place was to conceal its similarity to Gāochāng - Turpan, fortified city which was (differently from other cities in Tarim Basin) directly annexed very early to the Tang, by emperor Taizong (as quoted in the link you've provided, too) and turned into a seat of Anxi (protectorate to pacify the West) and the central commandery of 4 garrisons stationed in other four cities of Tarim Basin. The city, mainly populated by Han people (residing there for centuries together with merchants of other ethnicity), was full of soldiers, ie., definitely impregnable by some "black dragon" bandits, as it happened in the drama. It was impregnable even for a serious army, Tibetans conquered it only during Wu Zetian interregnum, after the complete withdrawal of the soldiers from the area and when they've already conquered Chang'an. In later Tang, the whole area was under Uyghur Khaganate, which had alternate close-distant (frenemy) relationship with Tang. Uyghurs converted en-mass to Manichaeism as to underline their closeness to Sogdians (who were Manichaeans) and distance from Tang (in late Tang, Manichaeism was banned and persecuted to the death). In that period of time, trade on the Silk Road was reduced only to what Uyghurs obtained directly from Tang - usually silk - as a compensation for military services they've offered from time to time to the Tang, helping Tang to quell rebellions (and sacking thoroughly rebelled cities in the process, as they've done twice with Luoyang, so the origin of traded South Chinese Sea pearls and other jewelry was more likely from the loots taken in those cities than from a fair exchange of goods), no way merchant caravans could have travelled so freely as shown in the drama on the route under the Uyghur protection, that trade was monopolized and even de-routed from cities in Tarim Basin to their capital in Ordu-Baliq
2.  Silk Road. I have no objections regarding the first part of your exposé (sea and river-canal routes), but as we see from point 1, unless the drama setting is in that brief period of Tang's direct military control of the road (and that setting would contraddict fictional events in the drama, in particular black dragon band), "pacified neighbourhood" mentioned in the drama never existed either. The trade itself (intended as free exchange with payment of local taxes for protection of the route), paradoxically saw better times during the Göktürks rule with trading centres like Turpan or Kashgar "decentralized", ie. given in management to local lords like Qus (who were ethnic Hans) of Gaochang. No wonder your links can quote written proofs of a flourishing exchange only for the period of time prior to Tang. But military expedition towards West was necessary, because Tibetan empire controlled the southern (south of Taklaman Desert and north of Kunlun Mt) route of the Silk Road, which connected Anxi and Dunhuang with Kashgar (the route taken by Marco Polo a few centuries later, after passing the Hindu Kush) threatening to cut out the northern, too, so the military deterrence was the only option left to secure the trade with regions referred as Transoxiana (geographical, politically neutral term). Gaochang/Turpan was strategic, there were two routes from that city, the southern along the southern side of Tian Shan through the desert leading to Kashgar and northern (north of Tian Shan and north of Issyk-Kul saline lake in today's Kyrgizistan) leading directly to Tashkent, Fergana valley, Samarkand... that route was more comfortable, with healthier environment compared to the desert and full of trading centres along the road...
3. Samarkand. During the period of expansion, Tang forces conquered it, toghether with the entire area of today's Uzbekistan which more or less coincides with Kāngjū (term in Chinese sources) and Sogdiana (Western sources),  establishing a protectorate over it and imposing tributary obligations to it. The term Kang has nothing to do with Samarkand, the link you've provided quotes different hypothesis for the origin of Chinese name among which the less credible is a distorsion of Tocharian "kanka" (one of the words for stone). Both Tocharian and Sogdian are Iranic (ie. highly mutually intelligible) languages. The meaning of Samarkand is "(fortified) city of stone", "-kand" in Iranic languages means city or fortification, it influenced (or was influenced by) Turkic languages in which -kent (as in Tashkent) has the same meaning. All five protectorates established by Tang were multiethnic melting pots and except for Anxi (losing it would directly harm Tang's interests and there was a direct threat at the time)... a very bad idea. With such a huge expansion (and obligation to protect in change of tributes), Tang overreached its capacities: Sogdiana and Tocharistan will be lost to Umayyad Chaliphate (who made Samarkand a center of Muslim expansion in Central Asia, razing Zoroastrian and Manichaean temples to the ground, forcibly converting or resettling its inhabitants) in Battle of Talas, significantly depleting Tang forces, while Mengchi and Kungling will be lost to the Second Turkic Khaganate.
This is how the history of the Silk Road during real Tang should be (more or less) outlined, we can't mix data from other, different period of times or sweeten the reality of the time only because we are watching a drama, we all know the reality is different from the fiction. The fact that the production hired an expert in history of pearl trade (who certainly helped with props, although he could have also tell them that other gems, like those YZJ shows to Duanwu are rarely spheric, especially there are no spheric emeralds in nature, they are crystal baryls) doesn't mean they didn't sacrifice true historical facts for the sake of storytelling of what is basically a fictional idol drama.
There are some other minor things, as for eg, "Hexi corridor is a long valley that starts north of Dūnhuáng " No, north of Dunhuang is Tarim basin, Taklaman Desert. The Hexi Corridor is a long, narrow passage stretching ("streched" between Qilian Shan and Gobi Desert) in northwest direction for some 1,000 kilometres from the steep Wushaolin hillside near Lanzhou to the legendary Yumen Pass also known as "Jade Gate".  Hexi corridor was a link, a passage obligé between "inner China" (fertile lowland with Central Plains) and so called "Western regions" which start passing Yumen. Dunhuang is the oasis in Western Regions situated on the southern route of Silk Road from city of Anxi (controlled by Tibetan imperial forces at the time).

Anyways, I also want to thank you because you've provided a lot of interesting information, even adding and explaining Chinese names and words (I'm not a Mandarin speaker), incredible work. I'll read your updates.

 Frost_edelweiss:

sorry for being non professional there

Believe me, I'm totally amazed by your skills, these maps look perfect to me (I wouldn't even know how to upload these charts here)! It isn't easy to make them at all, pinpointing the important locations, it's such a fortune to have you on MDL. I also feel your genuine enthusiasm to share with us what you've experienced in your travel there (I'm very grateful to you for this and understand when memory jumbles due to the emotion). I have friends from Croatia who are there right now, I've thought to go with them but wasn't completely satisfied with their agency trip planning (it includes too many days in other Chinese locations, while I was mostly interested in a route you've travelled, from Xi'an to Kashgar). I'll see them next summer, if they decide to return to this region, I'll go with them, if not, I'll find someone else to travel with.

 Frost_edelweiss:

I am not a gemmologist or a collector

Neither am I, I've just happened to see an emerald mine in Austria (Habachtal) when visiting NP of Hohe Tauern with my son (he was a kid back then), their baryls are formed ("geminated" is a technical term) in a schist matrix and although their texture is hard, they maintain the "schistose" property (schist derives from Greek verb σχίζειν, to split), so they can take only this baryl form and can be cut only in forms that respect linear and sharp angular "layers" typical for schist, which, despite being soft (containing a lot of granular material), splits along the plane in which the platy minerals lie. These forms are typical for quartz, too, and some types of quartz are formed in the schist as well. Tourists visiting Hohe Tauern can also search and freely take emeralds they found in schist blocks descarded in several water-courses. I am not particularly interested, but I often explore the mountains (Alps), so I regularly incidentally bump into museums or expositions of minerals, stones and gems, the last one was on Mt Blanc (the highest European peak, 4.800 m) Skyway 2nd cable stop at 3.800 m a.s., at the beginning of this year, quite a surprise (especially for a head buzzing due to the low air pressure), very rich and well-explained collection. That's the only reason why I've got some knowledge, without particularly searching for this matter. I personally rarely buy souvenirs but I'd not say no in front of the things you've collected along your journey. I have several (never worn) silk scarfs and fans gifted by people who returned from China, but I don't have cloisonné nail covers! Thank you for this hint, now I'll text to my friends telling them what I want as a gift from their trip, I'll certainly wear them, lol :)))))

 Frost_edelweiss:

Taklamakan is not north of Dūnhuáng

I had in mind the "southern route" of the Silk Road from Turpan, connecting Dunhuang with Kashgar via Hotan. Yes, it's westwards from Dunhuang, because the route is a mild semicircle, but generically, it's northwards from the middle part of the route. The first city conquered back then by Tibetan army was Hotan, where you've been, I've seen on internet the deposits of jade, that must have been an experience!

As for the drama... I agree with you it still offers some true geist of Tang and despite being disappointed with the turn it took, the first episodes promissed more power intrigue and despite irritating plot holes (in today's episode again, these black dragon bandits, first unexplainably abandoned by YZJ who must take his revenge over them, now pop out as illegal traders/transporters of looted jewerly, robbed from whom btw? This way of storytelling is just too weird), I continue to watch, as you see. It is true the props are better than in other dramas (and convey some true information to the audience, as CSJ said to Duanwu today: "jewerly is to communicate a status symbol") set in this period but this doesn't change the fact that the core plotline is quite common for costume idol-drama romance: from uncomfortableness to love -> misunderstanding & break-up -> FL collects her strenght, rises up, opens her own thriving business etc. So the meaning of "idol-drama" was not dismissing, it's just "we've seen this evolvement so many times", "it's not that original after all".

Thank you for this conversation, even if I don't enjoy the drama that much, I truly enjoy our exchange.

Thank you for your hard work!

This is amazing !

Thank you for this