ltspada
This review may contain spoilers
Well written coming of age, time travel, romance that is heartwarming
9.5/10 is my rating. This is 2023 South Korean Coming of Age, Time Travel, Fantasy romance. It has 16, 59-73 minute episodes.
First I provide a unique synopsis then review.
Synopsis
Han Eun Gyeol (Reyoun, Go Yoon-hwan) grew up in a household where the other family members, his dad, mom and older brother were all deaf and he acted as the interpreter and spokesperson for his entire family. It was a large burden for a young person, so he found refuge in the company of a grandfather figure who taught him to pay guitar at a local music shop. Growing up, he continues to pursue guitar but keeps it a secret as his father, Ha Yi Chan (Choi Hyun Wook) is determined his son become a doctor, or something else, to elevate the status of the family. Just when Eun Gyeol’s secret is discovered by his father, and they are amid a huge falling out, Eun Gyeol is transported back in time to 1995. A magical music store appears, because it has musical instruments he goes in, sells one of his guitars, then he steps out back in time. In the past, he encounters the younger version of his father, who is forming a band but is also very interested in a beautiful but icy cellist, Se Keyong (Seol In Ah) who is problematically not Eun Gyeol’s mother. To get his mother, Cheong Ah (Shin Eun Soo) and father together Eun Gyeol he has to join his father’s band and make it successful. Will he succeed in uniting his parents in this new past and can he return to his own timeline?
Review
I did not fully read the description before starting this series, so I was surprised it turned into a time travel show. I thought the main element was just going to be a family where most of the members were deaf. That would have been enough to write a compelling story, so when it switched to time travel, I was surprised. The switch from a family centered drama to a time traveling drama, would have been okay, but I did not feel they did it well. It was confusing a lot of times. The switches back in forth in time were not very clear at times. But then it got really good. It had a bit of a rough start, but the latter half of the series was very good. There were a few, relatively minor, issues in terms of time travel concepts. I liked it a lot and I am not a huge fan of time travel. The romance was not completely central to the story, it was more focused on the family relationships. But there were two very heartwarming romances. I liked this a lot, would definitely rewatch it and recommend it to anyone that likes time travel, romance, stories about musicians, magical content, or are fans of any of the actors.
Spoilers
I am not a fan of time travel series. I like things to happen in the order they occur. Switching back and forth between timelines can be confusing and I felt like this story suffered a lot in that process. For instance, when the younger version of the dad was first introduced, we were simultaneously following the main guy in the current time and I kept wondering who that character was and how they fit into the story. We hadn’t yet been introduced to the time travel so I was not considering the possibility it could be a younger version of one of the characters. After the big reveal on time travel, and I realized that was the younger version of the father, I had to mentally review what happened with that character. There were times when, rather than just abruptly change the scene to something that transpired earlier, they could have had a character reflect back so it was clearer the events happened in the past. Instead they just throw a scene in with past events and you wonder if that is present or past.
I found it annoying how oblivious the main character was to the fact that the people, in the past version of themselves, would not know who he was. I get it would be exciting to come across a young version of a parent, other relative, or close friend but you would have to temper that with the knowledge they haven’t lived the future yet. If they were time travelers too, sure call someone “dad” or “ajumma” but if you call someone that, who you are a stranger to, they will think you are crazy. And he didn’t just call them like that once, realize his error, and act like you would towards someone you just met, he continued to call them familiar titles. He persisted even when the person would say I don’t know you or why are you calling me that. I’m like dude they don’t know who you are. No wonder he is running from you, you seem crazy.
The main character, who is supposed to be super smart, not only didn’t realize people in the past wouldn’t know him, he was also really frustrating in getting practically any point across. Like when he is trying to convince the younger version of his dad he can play guitar, he doesn’t say let me play guitar and show you. So, they would be arguing about whether or not he is telling the truth about his musical abilities and there would be a guitar right there. I am like grab the guitar, and do a riff, that would convince your “dad” way more than any verbal argument. But they tease that through scene after scene until they finally have him playing and the dad hears him from a distance. There was the same frustrating situation with the past version of his mom. She is deaf, and the dad keeps misunderstanding her because he doesn’t know she is deaf, it has to be apparent to her that is going on yet she never grabs something and writes “I am deaf.” In both situations the situation could have been resolved quickly. And I get it is entertaining to have that carrot move as you are just about to grab it, but if you do that too much it quits being amusing and just becomes frustrating. And both were such smart people, it is not credible within each character that they would fail to think of something so obvious.
A “hole” in the time travel concept was when one of the main female leads traveled back in time and people mistook her for her mother, she let them think she was her. The grand plan was, she wanted her mom not to fall in love with her dad but with someone else. She was suicidal and figured if her “mom” fell for someone else, then she would never be born. But, the problem with that was, people thought she was her mom, but she wasn’t really her mom. Her mom was studying abroad. They never explained how her getting someone else to fall in love with her would have any impact on her mom’s future. So that was an inconsistency, to me, with the theories around time travel.
#TwinklingWatermelon #Ryeon #GoYoonHwan #JungHeyonJun #ChoiHyunWook #ChoiWonYoung #SeolInAh #LeeSoYeon #ShinEunSoo #SeoYoonHee
First I provide a unique synopsis then review.
Synopsis
Han Eun Gyeol (Reyoun, Go Yoon-hwan) grew up in a household where the other family members, his dad, mom and older brother were all deaf and he acted as the interpreter and spokesperson for his entire family. It was a large burden for a young person, so he found refuge in the company of a grandfather figure who taught him to pay guitar at a local music shop. Growing up, he continues to pursue guitar but keeps it a secret as his father, Ha Yi Chan (Choi Hyun Wook) is determined his son become a doctor, or something else, to elevate the status of the family. Just when Eun Gyeol’s secret is discovered by his father, and they are amid a huge falling out, Eun Gyeol is transported back in time to 1995. A magical music store appears, because it has musical instruments he goes in, sells one of his guitars, then he steps out back in time. In the past, he encounters the younger version of his father, who is forming a band but is also very interested in a beautiful but icy cellist, Se Keyong (Seol In Ah) who is problematically not Eun Gyeol’s mother. To get his mother, Cheong Ah (Shin Eun Soo) and father together Eun Gyeol he has to join his father’s band and make it successful. Will he succeed in uniting his parents in this new past and can he return to his own timeline?
Review
I did not fully read the description before starting this series, so I was surprised it turned into a time travel show. I thought the main element was just going to be a family where most of the members were deaf. That would have been enough to write a compelling story, so when it switched to time travel, I was surprised. The switch from a family centered drama to a time traveling drama, would have been okay, but I did not feel they did it well. It was confusing a lot of times. The switches back in forth in time were not very clear at times. But then it got really good. It had a bit of a rough start, but the latter half of the series was very good. There were a few, relatively minor, issues in terms of time travel concepts. I liked it a lot and I am not a huge fan of time travel. The romance was not completely central to the story, it was more focused on the family relationships. But there were two very heartwarming romances. I liked this a lot, would definitely rewatch it and recommend it to anyone that likes time travel, romance, stories about musicians, magical content, or are fans of any of the actors.
Spoilers
I am not a fan of time travel series. I like things to happen in the order they occur. Switching back and forth between timelines can be confusing and I felt like this story suffered a lot in that process. For instance, when the younger version of the dad was first introduced, we were simultaneously following the main guy in the current time and I kept wondering who that character was and how they fit into the story. We hadn’t yet been introduced to the time travel so I was not considering the possibility it could be a younger version of one of the characters. After the big reveal on time travel, and I realized that was the younger version of the father, I had to mentally review what happened with that character. There were times when, rather than just abruptly change the scene to something that transpired earlier, they could have had a character reflect back so it was clearer the events happened in the past. Instead they just throw a scene in with past events and you wonder if that is present or past.
I found it annoying how oblivious the main character was to the fact that the people, in the past version of themselves, would not know who he was. I get it would be exciting to come across a young version of a parent, other relative, or close friend but you would have to temper that with the knowledge they haven’t lived the future yet. If they were time travelers too, sure call someone “dad” or “ajumma” but if you call someone that, who you are a stranger to, they will think you are crazy. And he didn’t just call them like that once, realize his error, and act like you would towards someone you just met, he continued to call them familiar titles. He persisted even when the person would say I don’t know you or why are you calling me that. I’m like dude they don’t know who you are. No wonder he is running from you, you seem crazy.
The main character, who is supposed to be super smart, not only didn’t realize people in the past wouldn’t know him, he was also really frustrating in getting practically any point across. Like when he is trying to convince the younger version of his dad he can play guitar, he doesn’t say let me play guitar and show you. So, they would be arguing about whether or not he is telling the truth about his musical abilities and there would be a guitar right there. I am like grab the guitar, and do a riff, that would convince your “dad” way more than any verbal argument. But they tease that through scene after scene until they finally have him playing and the dad hears him from a distance. There was the same frustrating situation with the past version of his mom. She is deaf, and the dad keeps misunderstanding her because he doesn’t know she is deaf, it has to be apparent to her that is going on yet she never grabs something and writes “I am deaf.” In both situations the situation could have been resolved quickly. And I get it is entertaining to have that carrot move as you are just about to grab it, but if you do that too much it quits being amusing and just becomes frustrating. And both were such smart people, it is not credible within each character that they would fail to think of something so obvious.
A “hole” in the time travel concept was when one of the main female leads traveled back in time and people mistook her for her mother, she let them think she was her. The grand plan was, she wanted her mom not to fall in love with her dad but with someone else. She was suicidal and figured if her “mom” fell for someone else, then she would never be born. But, the problem with that was, people thought she was her mom, but she wasn’t really her mom. Her mom was studying abroad. They never explained how her getting someone else to fall in love with her would have any impact on her mom’s future. So that was an inconsistency, to me, with the theories around time travel.
#TwinklingWatermelon #Ryeon #GoYoonHwan #JungHeyonJun #ChoiHyunWook #ChoiWonYoung #SeolInAh #LeeSoYeon #ShinEunSoo #SeoYoonHee
Was this review helpful to you?
