I'm a tad disappointed with this short and I'm not sure that my ratings are accurate to my feelings, but I'll try to justify them. Honestly, I thought that this was just a teaser trailer for a series, especially when I saw first saw the photo above, when searching the non-existent seeries. I've not read the novel but I feel that there was definitely scope to make a series or a movie. I admit that I kinda feel cheated, which is why my anticipation to see this couple in Love By Chance was off the scale. Anyway, that aside, I liked the story, or at least what I thought was going to be the story. Considering the length, I felt too much time was spent on the lead up to the boys' meeting - it could have been achieved in half the time without affecting the story . I didn't have an issue with the 'obsession', in fact I thought it was sweet and unique. The story ends abruptly and every time I watch it I'm always left wanting more. I particularly like Title's character though I can't decide about Earth's. Is it that he's just too cute? I don't know. I don't feel that the short was long enough to honestly rate the acting. I found the music fitted the mood of the scenes well. I continually revisit this sweet little short quite often and will continue to do so whenever I need a sugar hit. I just wish someone would make this a series or movie.