jesterstear999
Wow, just Wow....
Firstly, this is based on an award nominated, highly regarded horror manga. I haven't read all the manga, but I did dip into the end of it to try and get some explanation, and the end differs significantly, but the main characters are instantly recognisable.I can honestly say that I have never seen anything like this before (and I doubt if I ever would on the BBC), but it is not my usual genre, so for all I know it could be run of the mill typical fare.
The characters are extreme caricatures, the plot veers from slapstick comedy to extreme violence, (including sexual violence) and jaw dropping craziness, made worse by the main characters acceptance that this is somehow normal.
Hoshino Mari is excellent and unrecognisable in her role of the belittled abused sidekick, who nevertheless is a tenacious detective, she looks just like her manga counterpart and plays the Stan Laurel to Tayama Ryosei's obnoxious, misogynist & abusive Oliver Hardy (he is also just like his manga counterpart). Takahashi Issei does a good job as the local Policeman out of his depth. The minor cast do a good job of projecting an aura of creepy malevolence behind a happy facade. The atmosphere struck me as 1950s Americana with the tv jingles at the end of each episode and Happy Valley vibe.
Did I like it? Not particularly. It was good enough that I kept watching trying to figure out what was going on, but I was left disappointed that there was only a superficial theory, and a lot of loose ends (I'm not a fan of films/dramas where you have to go to discussion groups to try and make sense of what happened, I like my endings unambiguous and obvious)
It wasn't sufficiently thought provoking that I spent time afterwards trying to puzzle it out, and it didn't give me nightmares!
The general consensus seems to be that Twin Peaks fans (a series I really didn't didn't like, or watch beyond a few episodes..) will love it, maybe this is true...
Was this review helpful to you?
Not as good as the manga...
Firstly, I chose to watch this for Suzuki Yuka. I thought she was under used in Nanba Mg5, and this is the only drama (so far) in which she has a major role.She was fine in this, some solid performances from the rest of the cast too, but I didn't like it overall as I thought the way it was presented ruined the story- the 4th wall stuff was way overdone. It takes the place of the internal monologues of the manga, except it doesn't, in the manga everyone's feelings and impressions are revealed but this 4th wall just serves as a lesson in retirement planning. (However it did teach me the rule of 72!)
There is also a really annoying running gag that just spoils things further.
I know manga adaptations are hard, as it is so difficult to condense thousands of pages into 8 episodes, but this seems to have ignored some of the best plotlines as well as changing the message- which is why I rated the story so low, if I were writing about the manga I'd give the story 7.5/8.0.
Overall I was left very disappointed by this one. (And to be clear, I hadn't read the manga when I watched the drama)
Was this review helpful to you?
Suspend your disbelief and enjoy!
Hashimoto Kanna (Kaguya-sama) plays an impossibly young Policewoman/Vet/Animal & Plant Expert (Hey, Japan right? Age is no barrier to an acting role. If obviously 35 year old men can play High School students, an 18 year old can play a fully qualified Vet/Animal Expert/Policewoman.) The series addresses the incongruity with a running joke about everyone she meets thinking she is cosplaying.As seems usual in her roles, the height difference between Kanna and the rest of the cast is over-emphasised, although not for comedy effect like in Tokumei!, I suppose the cosplay thing was enough for this series.
Watabe Atsuro plays a good part as usual, even if the slapstick does go a bit over the top sometimes!
The rest of the cast play comedic caricatures- 25 year old receptionist desperate to find a man, retired detective who hangs around offering advice- "when I was a detective I......", mother figure who continually makes tea, jealous & incompetent new boss obsessed with Utski, lap-dog ex partner, punch-bag junior detective, Policeman who worships Sudou.
Basically suspend your disbelief (Just who looks after that menagerie? it would be a full time job, never mind all the house visits.) and enjoy a somewhat light-hearted (Even though there is a brutal murder every episode, and a child abuse features in one episode too) show about animals and crime solving.
There is even a dance routine at the end of each episode!
I loved seeing the chemistry between the cast, they all seemed to be having a great time, and the animals were great too, I'd really like a second series even now, at least Kanna would look old enough to do her job!
Was this review helpful to you?
