This review may contain spoilers
Too long and boring
Another Chinese drama that unnecessarily dragged for twice as many episodes than necessary. There wasn't any actual plot, but a loosely put together romance/slice of life story.Everything that made the show interesting, SWAT action and disaster rescue, quickly fizzled out into a mundane slice of life story. Kelei and Mika, who were the only couple worth watching, got together early in the show and had an extremely vanilla relationship without any ups and downs. All the couples had no dynamic or sexual chemistry. The show often looked like a real life documentary just filming people hanging out.
Kelei/Mika were the most wholesome, but they acted like an old married couple. There was no tension, conflict, or sexual chemistry. Many of their scenes did not have any direction. They just bantered and played around. If they were a real life couple, they would've been a joy to watch. But this is a TV drama that needs conflict, especially for a young couple. They kissed a couple of times at the beginning of their relationship and that was the height of their romantic chemistry, never to be seen again. It was pretty unbelievable that the writers thought it was a good idea to write a young couple spending so much time alone and never making out.
Wenbo/Qingxia were plain toxic. She arbitrarily started liking him after meeting him maybe twice and began pursuing him. He also liked her, but for some stupid reason kept rejecting her. Instead of moving on after being repeatedly rejected, she kept pursuing him and he kept rejecting her. His lame explanation later on revealed that he was rejecting her because he thought she was better matched with another guy. Seriously? And, this tripe lasted for 30+ episodes. When they finally got together, I couldn't care less. I actually ended up skipping most of their scenes because their bickering was exhausting.
Chief Shao/Sister Keyao were just ok. In most of their scenes, they spent time together without any romantic chemistry. There was nothing interesting about them at all.
Overall, the drama would've been a lot better if it was cut by half and had a lot more conflict and romantic chemistry. Instead, we had to watch scenes upon scenes of young people acting like they've been married for decades. The story was boring a lot more often than it was exciting. There were a lot of filler scenes of characters just doing mundane things. I ended up skipping through a lot in the last ten episodes just to get it over with. The last three episodes with the hostages were interesting, everything between the beginning and the end was a snooze fest.
Was this review helpful to you?
It's a lot.... but yes, we got through it :)
I think this had an interesting direction. I was wondering how they were going to incorporate medical and crime and romance all together, but I'd just label this mostly a romance drama. Anyhow, my thoughts are pretty simple here:1. Acting is pretty good and I like the lead couple and 3rd lead couple. There's a lot of communication and chemistry in these relationships, as well as cuteness. Obstacles have NOTHING on Xing Kelei and Mi Ka. I really appreciate the realism in the portrayal of first love (shy, a little bashful).
2. Pacing and story are a little muddled though. There are super long arcs, the second lead couple just made me skip all their scenes and the story doesn't really effectively navigate crime and medical arcs. They don't feel necessary, to be honest, and that bothers me a little. Just a tad?
I think if you do something in a drama, do it well. If not, don't do it at all. I do also think the romance did get in the way of realism for depicting special forces and hospital activity. I think the drama definitely serves in bringing your attention to first responders, but it's pretty damn romanticized.
3. I did watch all of it. It's pretty binge-worthy, and I am a binger. I did keep on pressing the forward five seconds button though :/
I could honestly see myself rewatching this.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
They are heroes
This was so cute, fun and serious at the same time.This is the longest drama I watched and finished so I'm proud because I mostly can't watch long dramas, I get distracted or bored towards the end. Sometimes it seems like a big commitment so I don't even start them.
The beginning episodes were slow, the ones where they train, I was waiting for something interesting to happen. Then the middle was fun and I got bored around ep 32 where two evil sisters appear wanting to destroy our main characters happiness. I thought instead of that they should have put another case where they save lives.
The ending is happy and cute, a little rushed with a case that lasts one episode. I think it's there to show their growth and make things dramatic but they already went through so much, they deserve a little bit of happiness and peace.
Thing's I liked
- The characters, I liked everyone except two sisters that show up towards the end.
- The relationships between the characters, the friendship, it was so cute and heartwarming.
- Mi Ka and Ke Lei being a healthy couple that talks about their problem's.
- Shu Wen Bo and Qing Xia being a chaotic couple.
- Shao and Ke Yao slowly getting together.
- Ke Yao is cool as a sister and as a friend.
- The cases where they save lives, they were well done.
- Showing the importance of police and doctors.
- The comedy, I laughed so much watching this.
Overall, it's an okay story with great characters.
Was this review helpful to you?
The Golden drama
This drama is really really good and interesting l love this so much fun and really need to watch The best the best I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2 I need season 2Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The chemistry is so natural - just gotta sit through!
The FL and ML's chemistry is undeniably strong. During their scenes, I feel like I'm just watching something in real life because of how natural they are with each other. Of course at the beginning of the series and beginning of their relationship they are awkward with each other especially being each other's first love, which I think is really nice because it really depicts how it is usually when you first start liking someone and being their other half. Throughout their relationship, they got comfortable with each other and their bickering was my favourite. Seriously. It felt so real and natural. They really are like a quarrelsome lovers, but yet so cute. Because of this, I actually really started shipping them two and would be nice if they really dated in real life. The relationship didn't these stupid misunderstandings and I love how at one point they weren't happy with something and have improved themselves and shared what they are feeling. I feel like because of this, they didn't have those annoying misunderstandings. The part with the childhood friend's arrival, no matter how pissed I am at those sisters, I watched through because of how good and strong Mi Ka's character is, like I'm sure it annoyed her, but I love her professional she was and how she handled things and not letting what they said get to her. Just like Mi Ka, I like how Ke Lei had handled in too (most of the time). Like he was aware that it could upset Mi Ka and he still was careful. Honestly liked the ending, but I wish I got to see their wedding, calling each other husband and wife and having kids. I honestly would have loved loved it. Also love how there was no unnecessary love triangles.The second FL and ML had the loooooooongest chasing. Xiao Xia's personality is really to be commended. Like wow how she chased Wenbo but just like everyone else, she got tired too. But that's when Wenbo also got his shit together. I really just wanna mention how much of a blockhead he is. It's cute at times but oh my days, he would need some serious teaching haha but in the end, he managed to pull his shit together.
I would like to write a separate paragraph for Xing Ke Yao. At the start when she first came out, I had this feeling that she would be such a bitchy sister and would cause unnecessary drama to the FL and ML. But how she dealt a lot of situations, especially when those two sisters came into the picture, I was at the top of the world. She is so badass honestly! Her strong personality and how she just quickly handled those two, I was waiting for it to come. I love whenever Ke Lei turns to his sister and they would discuss his situations, I love whenever she just listens to him like an amazing sister she is.
About the story, of course I've seen DOTS, but I was particularly drawn into this because I feel like it would bring me something strong in terms of their professions but also lighter when it comes to their drama. I have not seen a particular SWAT drama before and I was really curious about it and I'm glad I watched this. With both their professions having different types of work times, you can see how difficult it is to be together, especially the many times their dates got cancelled because of Ke Lei's missions. Mi Ka's patience, understanding and love for him I feel is what really made her stay no matter how difficult it is. I like that there's a good balance of medical and SWAT missions in this drama. Got to taste best of both worlds. I salute these healthcare professionals and the police force for protecting the populations. Honestly, it's not easy. Just wanted to say though, since it's also a medical drama and I'm sure they consult with a medical professional, I hope they improve on one thing, the rhythms lol. It really cracks me up whenever they have an emergency and they're like "there's heartbeat" and they show the oxygen saturation line s the "heartbeat" instead of the actual heart beat line. It did not only happen once but every time.
As for the OST, I didn't really pay attention to it much especially I skip the start and ending songs. But at one point of the series, they were playing the ending song, I really felt it in my heart. It's honestly one of my faves now. The other songs are good too.
One last thing and a big spoiler, when in the final ep, I had a feeling Ke Lei would propose again will have some sort of stunt to propose, and this may sound so cliche but when he finally said "Will you marry me", I felt my such goosebumps. To top that up, when Mi Ka answered "yes", I felt another set of goosebumps. It's unreal. i am glad to have watched this drama. I also felt like I know a lil bit more about SWAT too. Kudos to the team and actors!
Was this review helpful to you?
The beginning of the story was good
It would be better if the number of episodes was reduced further.The beginning of the story was good, I was very interested in how dramatic the FL and ML meeting was depicted. I really liked the shooting in this drama at the beginning and this is also what made me first interested in seeing it.
but unfortunately the storyline became boring in the next 20 episodes, I skipped a lot because there were a lot of things that didn't need to be explained but appeared and that made me ask, what's the point?
the acting was good, I felt the chemistry between the two main characters and also the supporting characters
As for the OST, I remember but didn't really enjoy it
I know this is a slow burn drama, but for a genre like this I think it could be simpler and straight to the point
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Something Magical
Despite not being a fan of love dramas in general, 你是我的城市营垒 was simply special.This drama tells the story of two lovers, who are both in highly specialized professions. A central theme of this story is responsibility, whereby it serves as the main 'antagonist' in their relationship and it feels very real (despite the odds of a doctor marrying a SWAT police). The execution of the medical and special forces scenes are really interesting and it helps to seamlessly weave the two protagonists arcs together (hooray for combined profession scenes).
(Side note: The responsibility and commitment Mika and Shao Yuhan showed as doctors, are truly inspirational)
I must confess that I was not that interested in Mika and Xing Kelei relationship at the start. But overtime, I grew to love their dynamic and the scenes these two share. Their struggle feels very real, and how they both grow to overcome their shortcomings together. The subplots of the supporting characters' love story are entertaining to watch as well. Importantly, this drama did not force many typical tropes and clichés (*cough* amnesia) and feels very refreshing as a story.
I will miss the days of listening to the ending music and really glad for my friend to recommended this drama. So for those who have yet to see this drama, it is definitely worth a watch!
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the few modern drama I truly enjoyed recently
It started with female doctor and special force (swat) policeman met in scary circumstances. From the very first scene, it was very dramatic and if you are not good at medical and violent scene, it may be bit difficult to watch but it was very realistic to me and story was convincing. Drama reminds me of US TV show ‘ER’ and other Swat police drama. It is well made.There are three CP stories in this drama. I usually don’t care about second or other CP and I end up skipping it. But this drama made all three CP stories well and I didn’t even skip any scenes. Three CP had their own dilemma and stories of this love life , and I really enjoyed them all.
ML and FL ‘s chemistry made this drama very realistic and they were so cute together. And ML looked so handsome in uniform and I ended up becoming a big fan if him and I am searching his drama to watch now.
Was this review helpful to you?
The model couple Xing Duizhangand Mi Yisheng
●HOW I CAME TO ITMy adherent admiration for uniform brought me to YOU ARE MY HERO. also Military Medical is my favorite genre
●FIRST IMPRESSION
Art speaks when the words are unable to explain the magical feeling.
I thoroughly enjoyed it to the extent that I was in disbelief that I watched the 40episode long drama and it just ended.
●PLOT VIEW
I just flowed with the story, it was simple and that's the reason it became addictive. It is one of the best dramas showing healthy and trustful relationships with clean plots. If there isn't a need for the couples to break up or fight or misunderstand, they can solve each problem with healthy conversations.
The opening scene had intense action followed by a drill session unfolding a gripping story. It shifts from the military and medical profession showing intense hard work. The earthquake story was a catastrophe but this contrasted with their trustful relationship. After every patient, they part ways but nature brings them closer. Also, the disease and sister's plot was written carefully, giving their relationship an evolution.
It might feel boring in the introductory episodes because the romance is slow. it doesn’t escalate but takes on Mika and Kelei journey of falling for each other, pursuing, proposing, and the first kiss. they were not charming or cute but has the poise of simplicity. They both are dedicated to their work, so they don’t have time for love, after getting into a relationship they build respect and care for each other works. Although they are mature adults their intimacy and shyness are totally adorable and give unique vibes. Kelei tries to pursue but Mika doesn't pick the hints, It had a slice of life feel.
Shu wenbo and Ruan Qingxia also had an amazing story. It felt forced during the starts, as Xia was quite bold, but as they develop into a love triangle it felt heartwarming. Dating tips for wenbo were really fun to watch. Qingxia was straightforward and lovely. Her relationship with Mika is besties goals where they support, complain, help and love like true friends without much talk.
Xing Keyao and Shao Yuhan developed their love story at their own pace realizing and respecting their mistakes. Most essentially giving the second chance to themselves. They had less screen time but had a good plotline, not just screen filler.
●ACTING/CAST
Flawless, it might feel too simple in the starting but when kept on watching they grew on me with every breath. The chemistry of all the three couples was heartwarming. Kisses were sweet like candyfloss, I couldn’t stop smiling watching them. Each relationship whether it was mentor-mentee, siblings, colleagues, or friends, had some spark to touch the heart.
Bai Jing Ting as Captain Xing KeLei, Excellent. I couldn’t imagine any other actor would be fit for this role. He is the youngest captain to lead the team, sure his sculpted muscular lean body with optimum expressions is amazing. The special police uniform enhances his cool, rusty, and youthful demeanor. He is tough infront of others but shows his vulnerable side to the one.
Sandra Ma as Dr. MiKa was Ace, firstly I felt the acting to be flat but as the story flows in those expressions were priceless. She made Mika alive with her hardworking and kind nature at the workplace, with a shy and cute girl to her lover.
●MUSIC
It was magical, the opening track is meaningful, I didn’t skip while watching the drama. The tracks were synchronized at the right moments.
●REWATCH
Am totally up for it. This slow-burn romance with a healthy relationship is hard to find.
●APPRECIATION
>Two of the most hardworking professions and their dynamics in the relationship were explored greatly.
> The parallel scenes of calm mood while treating patients, he practices in the ground makes my heart race.
>Parade of special police
●CRITICISM
>It might only be the medical cases dealt with, it was like a facade and surgeries was also quick, only if it had more detailing, it would have been awesome but then it wasn’t a medical drama.
> I wished to see more of Wenjing being the only female special police in the team. It had a great potential story but was left ignored.
●FAV SCENE
>The preliminary scene, with the scenario of the first meet. It was intense and a spectacular start.
>Birthday surprise was lit.
●RECOMMENDATION
It is for all those who love simple romantic dramas. This won't make you cry, but teach you how to love and trust in a relationship. How not to give up on it because of stressful jobs.
●QUOTES
I have been handsome since I was a child. It is not my fault, people like to enjoy wonderful things - Captain Xing Kelei
When will a doctor feel useless? When you find you have learned a lot but at last you cant overcome something called Fate - Dr. Shao Yuhan
●WISDOM
Xing Kelei and Mika are such model couples, loyal to their countries, kind, and faithful to their love towards each other. They loved each other selflessly and were supportive of their jobs.
●AFTERTHOUGHT
Every person in uniform works hard to secure a safe life for society and maintain peace. whether doctor, police, or any other, respect them because they leave their loved ones and family to serve other people of the nation.
With that all the people who save us from bad people, bad situations, and save lives, YOU ARE MY HERO.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Putting One's Life on the Line to Save Others - These are Our Heroes
I came to this drama late even though I was aware of it. Nonetheless, I decided to give it a go after (sort of) running out of good dramas to watch. I like the ML as I think he is fine actor even though he isn't the most handsome out there. I have watched quite a few of his dramas and he has left a positive impression on me. The FL is decent IMO.What I Liked:
- The cast was very good. Generally very natural acting. Ke Yao and Yu Han were fantastic in their acting. I really believed they were who they were supposed to be. I was quite blown away by their great acting. The supporting cast like Li Nian and others were generally pleasant to watch too.
- The OST was quite catchy.
- There were dramatic moments in this drama.
- Happy ending.
What I Didn't Like So Much:
- Some parts were draggy and I found that I reached for the FF button quite a lot for this drama. Not a big deal but yeah, some parts were rather repetitive and draggy.
- The love lines were not combusting with heat. Rather, the love lines were more of slow burn for Ke Lei and Mi Ka, Wen Bo and Qing Xia as well as Yu Han and Ke Yao. Relatable and realistic build up of relationships which is good but I much prefer a bit more heat and sizzle.
Overall, I enjoyed this drama and am happy to give it a high-ish 8.5/10
:o)
This is a good drama to watch and will make you look forward to the next episode. Nonetheless, you may want to get your remote control ready to press FF when the going gets a little slow.
Was this review helpful to you?
Ep 1-20 are epic
Will give this drama a 10 if only the plot wasn't dragged too much from the halfway of the drama. I really enjoy watching the first 20 episodes of this drama. Epic. Very addicting, just want to watch another then another episodes..... until episode 20. Starting ep 21-37.5 though, I think the story lost its essential story and more focused at the romance between the leads (actually, imo this is the problem with most c-dramas). For me, it became super draggy, and I skipped and fast forward a lot. The plot became interesting again at halfway ep 37, until the series ended at ep 40. These 3 last episodes are worth waiting.Superb acting. The chemistry between the lead couple is very good. Love the ost so much, esp the ending/closing song.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
THE MOST PERFECT AND LIGHT DRAMA <3
If you are looking for a drama that is sweet, fluffy and light, then this drama is for you. It's literally perfect. The leads chemistry is off the charts. Every cast is perfect. There are no frustrating misunderstandings and break ups. There are no evil character, only sweet and good side characters. The love story is really cute and mature type. You'll see how the leads progress through their relationship with each episode. They do not take their relationship fast, instead they naturally take their relationship forward. Talking about male and female lead, no one could have pulled off better than them.The male lead is a tough, strict and an excellent special policeman whereas the female lead is a kind and passionate doctor. They will also show you the lives of doctor and policeman too. The male lead is not arrogant and he never acted like jerk. He was very in love with the FL. The FL wasn't the typical crybaby. She was smart, cute and a ball of sunshine. The side couples are also very cute. There are no unnecessary story line. It's like watching someone fall in love in real life. I was very attached to their love story. You want to be in a relationship like them while watching this drama because its literally perfect.
After watching strong chemistry in dramas like CLOY, weightlifting fairy kim bok joo, What's wrong with secretary kim and so on, this dramas couples are top tier and you'll enjoy watching this drama. Trust me and watch this drama if you are looking for a sweet, fluffy drama with mature leads and good cast.
Was this review helpful to you?