There were a few too many tropes for me to fully throw my heart into giving it a 10 though. I wanted to like it a bit more than I actually did. It wasn't slow, it wasn't dumb, it wasn't poorly scripted or acted but something just didn't work for me for some reason. I can't say exactly what. Maybe I was just over tired or distracted by my life. Who knows.
I would definitely recommend this drama. It's unique enough to not feel like you've seen it a billion times. It's a typical love story, true, but the writers play a bit to make it clever and cute.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
And I was completely sucked into the K dramaland with this one.
Loved the story, original and kept giving me plot twists and tears. It made me cry, and that was powerful as I first entered the dramaland.
I loved the actors, especially the FL and ML, they are among my favourite korean actors. They had great chemistry too, and definitely believable love was shown. Also Loved the main Villain, a great actor he is.
This show is definitely one of the more romantic korean dramas out there, and the special effects were great along with the action. Definitely bravo to the director and production team.
The music was amazing, Hyorin was singing one of their songs.
The main song my destiny is great and well fitting.
I have already rewatched this drama 3 times, and will definitely rewatch again.
Thank you for reading my review! :)
Was this review helpful to you?
Overall, I really enjoyed this drama. It was a little long for my taste and maybe the back and forth sabotaging could have been cut down a lot, but I loved how it was a drama about an alien who lived on earth for almost 400 years, but in his last 3 months, he learned what it was like to be human. I loved the little lessons he would teach in his class and how they were different traits on animals and humans on earth and how they tied into his life, going through the different feelings of human relationships. I also loved, even though it made me ugly cry, how the ending was a lot more realistic than a typical happily ever after. They took one of the biggest issues with their relationship and actually made it a real issue that couldn't easily be solved by true love, but instead made it a situation where regardless of what happened, they would find their happily ever after and fight for one another and make it work. It wasn't ideal, but they were able to conquer their own doubts and insecurities about their relationship and able to live a happy life.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
First but not the last
My first ever drama. I searched the internet of what is the highest rated one it spat out this one.Maybe its nostalgia however, it really has not kept up with the time. Its unrealistic and too cliche. The male lead was the highlight and is still one of the most normal looking Korean male I have seen.
The story now feels dumb as I think about it. It had poor pacing and nothing really clicked for me.
How the heck these two leads get in love I am confused. And how is everyone else so low IQ and cant figure out a person not aging for centuries is beyond me. It requires a lot of subversion of logic but still it is not the best watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
Cliché Done Right
I was skeptical about this one because I knew it had some older graphics which are very obvious in the current times and really spoil the whole experience for me in general. However I was pleasantly surprised with how the show unfolded. It was light, breezy with a hint of melodrama, how these cliches tend to be. I LOVED Jun Ji hyun, both her performance and her character, it was the comic relief that I needed and actually laughed at her quirks. Kim Soo-hyun also grew on me over the course of the show but I would have been bored to death if it weren't for Song I (FML).The epilogues were a nice touch and I really enjoyed them. The SML also actually played a role in taking the story forward which is kind of nice. Everyone else did a good job but I really did not care about them because the chemistry between the MLs was so good. There was nothing new in the story, but the delivery was funny and engaging. The melo was in check, just the right amount. I would have wanted to know more insight about the ML's life before he came to earth and not just his life on earth but even I know that is asking too much from a rom-com.
The OST is fantastic, the cinematography is good, considering this drama was released 9 years ago. This show has aged well and I can see myself watching it again after a couple of years.
Was this review helpful to you?
I really need a season 2. I did not expect it would be the way it was,i didn't even expect to cry. Both actors and actresses made the drama so real and emotionally accurate.Hands down Jun Ji Hyun and Kim Soo Hyun are one of the bests out there. And i'm not even talking about the plot...WHAT AN AMAZING MASTERPIECE . I'm dreaming on marrying a korean,but f this idea. NOW I NEED A KOREAN ALIEN.
And I don't even watch sci fi dramas or movies,but this was perfect. It had that twist of sci fi but it wasn't overwhelming at all.
So overall,this is a quality drama that is definitely worth watching. Visually stunning, at times absolutely hilarious, and at other times, deeply touching. *YOU ARE MYYY DEEEESTINYYY*
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Tearjerker that I almost missed
I binge watched this whole drama in one sitting, I'm not kidding. I had dropped this after watching a few minutes and tried to watch it many times, then I sat down and started watching, since I noticed Yoo In Na was in it. I stayed for the romance and unexpected events.I cried everytime Song Yi cried, I honestly don't know if it's because I was really into the acting or maybe Jun Ji Hyun had an amazing crying face and it made me cry also. lol
I loved how Song Yis family was reunited and her mother realized her love of money wasn't as important as her family.
I feel like I keep saying I loved, but honestly the music was so great! Those really made the scenes. The actors and actresses were a fantastic choice and the visuals weren't that bad considering the year it was released.
When the end was near I was a bit afraid that the ending would be like Edward Scrissorhands and they wouldn't meet again at all, I was wishing for ending like My Roommate Is A Gumiho. And the result was neither one of them which made me happy and sad. It was unique.
It's definitely worth a watch!!
Was this review helpful to you?
All these years later, this drama holds up marvellously. While early episodes suffer a bit from the overacting, pettiness and villains of your average daytime melodrama/soap, the plot settles in on something a little more profound. Sure, there isn't a point to many of the minor/supporting characters, but it's hard to mind when the drama stayed engaging and kept pace in so many other ways.
The key of course is in the main couple as both actors play the opposites attract chemistry to perfection. You instantly believe Kim Soo-Hyun as the cold, cynical intellectual alien with a bit of a naive younger vulnerability and Jun Ji-Hyun as a dramatic, ambitious and self-involved star actress who pretends to be cynical but actually shares a similar vulnerability. Not only are they excellent on screen separately, but they have a great sense of comedic, romantic and tragic timings.
The big weak point in this drama is the music feels dated and overwhelms some of the scenes. The drama has good rewatch potential.
I grade other criteria as well:
Complex Themes - 7.5
The explicit theme is that loving and caring for others makes a life worth living and creates the feeling of home. A theme I enjoyed was that it's better to commit to love even if the future is uncertain, rather than a relationship without love just because of finances and societal expectations. Also, sometimes you need to let family members suffer the consequences of their actions.
Character Growth - 8
Both characters become more vulnerable, and human over the course of the show. They are not the same in the beginning as they are in the end (though the character growth is predictable).
Complex Female Characters/Dynamics - 7
Cheon Song I is a great character - full of ambition and joy for life. She, however, has a typical frenemies relationship with fellow friend/actress and conflicts with her stage mother.
Production Budget/Design/Cinematography - 8
The wealthy characters have lovely penthouse flats, great clothing, well-designed spaces etc. There's lots of shots outdoors not just on sets, there's some decently creative takes on how to display Do Min-Jun's powers especially his ability to stop time and walk through doors into other spaces. Very few of the special effects feel super dated which shows how much thought must have been put into it.
Was this review helpful to you?
Like no other, it had you interested all the time their was no boring part which you could skip.
I loved the main couples chemistry it was touching you would wonder in every episode how the couple was going to end up.
Yes I found the ending nice very good I guess but I was a bit upset because I thought it would have ended a different way but overall it was awesome.
Was this review helpful to you?
Not the best, not the worst
I found it hard to like Song Yi for the first couple of episodes. She was so rude and entitled, it was difficult to root for her, but thankfully her awful behavior lessened as the show went on.The leads had amazing chemistry and were great. Their interactions were believable and the emotional scenes felt real. I didn't cry at any point, but this has to be one of the top 5 dramas I've seen, that isn't inherently sad, where characters cry at least once each episode. And very convincingly, mind you.
The supporting characters were also very good. I particularly loved Hwi Kyeong, with his steadfast, unwavering love for Song Yi (he was so sweet, I wouldn't have been mad if the show had ended with a trouple forming LOL), the friend with the comic book store who continually fell in love with every good looking guy she saw and also Song Yi's bratty little brother.
Honestly, for a 21 episode show, it didn't feel that long. It did drag a bit at certain times, but there were surprisingly few "flash-back" scenes, and lots of interesting, interconnecting plots that kept things fresh and moving along nicely.
The OST was a bit cheesy, but maybe that has to do with when this drama came out? IDK.
All in all, story-wise, nothing too mind blowing, but with very strong performances all around that make it worth watching.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?