Finale is - _ -
The story until episode 14 was great, so much wholesome moments and all. I love their interactions. Totally worth it. The casts are very good. They all did a good job displaying the characters. Most of the episodes was totally worth it... BUTThe ending is the most annoying thing ever. I won't spoil anything. I hate it but It's okay I guess. The thing is I feel so empty after the final scene. Can't they explain more about why he DID IT???
Anyways.. You'll get triggered but It's a very good kdrama.
Byee
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Great casting and cute story but terrible, disappointing ending
Honestly i really loved watching this drama, I remember watching it every Wednesday while it was airing... I'm always happy when they normalise nunna relationships as well!But dang those last like what? 20 mins? ruined the whole thing lol i dont know what they were thinking?! I honestly just kinda erase that part from my memories which is why the overall rating i put isn't that bad.
The fact that he faked his own death??? To avoid truly breaking up with her and hurting her? That's the stupidest thing it makes me so mad. The entire storyline was so cute and the actors were so adorable too and I loved the piano theme and the soundtrack and the dynamics between the characters etc. I was truly disappointed when they ruined the ending this way. Sure they end up together but it's not even satisfying.
I wouldn't ever be able to rewatch this knowing the dumb ending, although I don't regret watching it in the first place because as I said, it's really only the last part of the last episode that's ridiculous.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Bad ending to a good series
Big fan of GoAhRa, she plays her role pretty well in anything thrown at her. You are surrounded, Hwarang all good series to watch.I have no complaints with her acting in this as well. A go easy stupid girl starts learning about the world.
Lee was also pretty good hilarious how even I was surprised by his roles age. He played character to the sleeve showing the kind of childish love but a mature exterior in the worldly things.
The support cast was brilliantly fit into the main story without them the story would not come along. It was very pleasant to watch till episode 14. It has the comedy, suspense, and love requires for the series. Till the big bomb dropped.
But even then it was pretty good the ML is written off as dead in episode 15 by the mother. But the nonsense was the climax the last 2 mins of the episode 16. I was ok with him dying also and that the FL was living with his love and memories etc.
Then he comes back from the dead what ??!!!
They should have either let him be dead or changed the way the conversation went between the mother and FL in episode 15 or atleast the reduced the time forward in episode 16. 5 F yrs, are you crazy who would believe that a guy u loved and mourned for 5yrs comes back from the dead.
Crazy stuff, my suggestion end the series 2 mins before the climax of episode 16 and u will go home with a satisfied series, though a sad ending but u will not lose the love u had for it for 16 episodes u watched
Was this review helpful to you?
Sweet story
I enjoyed this drama. I love Go Ah Ra, she’s one of my favorite actresses, and this was a perfect role for her. Lee Jae Wook is a new favorite for me. I loved him in Extraordinary You, I was happy to see him in a lead roll. Jun and RaRa had great chemistry, I thought. The mystery behind DoDoSolSolLaLaSol was fun to try and figure out. The rest of the cast were endearing and it was fun to follow their story lines. Some people had issues with the age difference between the leads, not that it was that big of a gap, but he was still in HS. When you fall in love with someone, you don’t think “oh, I’m not old enough to fall in love with her yet.” I thought their maturity levels matched well, he was younger but acted older and she was older but seemed younger.I don’t tend to over analyze kdramas, I watch for the entertainment factor, so I can’t tell if there were plot holes or anything like that. I was entertained by this drama and looked forward to it every week. I thought the ending was a tad wonky, but it was a happy one, so I was satisfied.
If you looking for a fluffy filler, this would be a cute drama to watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
A very good drama that had a disappointing ending ?
I really enjoyed watching this drama. The cast was amazing in my opinion, the main leads and the supporting roles were all fantastic. There was a point where I thought that this was gonna be one of the best dramas of all time but towards the ending I felt like there were too many unnecessary things happening and the last episode completely let me down. I would not say it was a sad ending and I hate sad ending as they make my heart cry for days but maybe a sad ending would have been a better option for this drama. It’s overall a very good drama that you’ll enjoy, apart from the ending🥰Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
MAJOR SPOILER I WAS JUST SO ANGRY
So, I've watched this around late 2021. My mom was diagnosed with cancer, and I was looking for some soft, sweet kdrama to watch and this seemed to be just it. That is until I got to the finale.As I mentioned, my mom was diagnosed with lymphoma and was hospitalized around the time I watched this. So I bawled my eyes out when they decide to kill the main character, just to find out 20 min later, in the final like 5 min that the son of a great mother was freaking alive!! I didn't even know how to feel.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
RED FLAG
First half was okay. Second Half, I honestly don't know what happened.Not the biggest fan of Go Ara's acting. I honestly watched this because of Lee Jaewook and I needed a light drama to watch. At first, I was really hooked into the drama. I kept on looking forward to the next episode but some where, some how, it started making me lose interest.
The biggest disappointment here is actually the ending, the last few minutes of it to be exact. Like, who the heck pretends to be dead for 5 years? making all his loved ones suffer and grieve. That right there is a HUGE red flag. It's just mental plain mental torture.
I must admit, the beginning was really cute and entertaining but as the show went on the plot started getting sloppier and sloppier.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Plenty of other shows
It seems like it has some good things going for it, but in the end it's as if all the cliches in dramaland were thrown in a blender and pasted together in the most unnatural way. The disappearing act is a bad enough cliche...but never has it been done as poorly here (and it usually is done poorly). The dude literally acts like it's no big deal and entirely logical. Leads didn't seem well matched but at least it has Ye Ji Won who always seems to elevate her roles. The best way to watch it is to make a game out of it. When ever something is about to happen see who can guess it beforehand. Hint...just think of something tired and ridiculous and that probably is what will happen.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
My first short review - but sometimes you can't keep quiet
In Fact: I loved the chemistry between the leads. I laughed out loud in the first half of the drama and also shed a tear a few times. In short: the drama captured me completely. I loved almost every support character and I literally adored the ladies in the beauty salon. (Get a divorce! Yeah!) But the second half .... sigh. Then you start thinking about all the things that happened and put them together and this is what comes out:Positive aspects:
great actors and great chemistry
my favourites: the ladies in the beauty salon - so irresistible
Story: WTH??
Everything bad that can happen does happen and even more.
In the second half of the drama, I felt completely lost and hopeless because, unfortunately, the script-writers took out any lightness between the leads and added one horrible thing after the other as if there were no tomorrow .
A lot of bad things happened in the first half too, but you were always compensated for it with Ra Ra's bright optimism and her influence on those around her (Put it on my bill! So cute.).
And at the end I thought: After all the mess, you only need around two minutes to sort things out and that in one run?
REALLY??? That even beats the drama Bride of the Century.
The good points in the overall rating above are really almost entirely dedicated to the actors.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
i had too much hopes for this drama
when i first started to watch this drama, i really thought it's going to be a good one and i just had too much hopes for this. great acting and music, and great chemistry with a good plot but it's just too crappy at the end of the drama, with the main character getting a major health issues and sending him abroad to save the life and years going without communicating and lying about the male lead dying and suddenly appearing after 5 years. it just good too much going at the end and the drama had too much confusion in it . it was great story at the begging but the end was worst, just not a good ending .:((( i finished this a long time ago but i just never wanted to write a review until today. it's just a complete NO for this drama.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Entertaining but problematic ending
This Kdrama is very entertaining; the characters are appealing and the story line is engrossing. But, as explained below, the ending wasn’t just bad, it was offensive.Recommendation: Watch it, then read the spoilers, not just mine but others. What’s nice about this story is that its the characters are well-developed and memorable. And because of that, the conclusion provokes a powerful reaction. That’s also part of the fun.
Spoiler: Let's talk about the ending. Here's the setup: The endearing Goo Ra-ra befriends, then falls in love with, Sunwoo Joon. Despite his independence, he's actually a much younger runaway high school student. Joon leaves Ra-ra to study abroad. Ra-ra hosts a Christmas party, which is also a homecoming party for Joon. His mom shows up instead and reveals Joon had gone overseas for cancer treatment and sadly passed away. Five years later, the last few minutes of the show, Joon returns to a joyful reunion.
Wait, what? He didn't die? Is this suppose to be a happy ending?
The Problems:
First, it didn’t just undermined a very touching and well-earned reconciliation scene between Joon’s mother and Ra-ra; it perverted it. To tell someone their beloved just died, when it fact that person is alive, is beyond mean - it’s evil.
Second, what does it say about Joon’s character? Again, lying about his death and not keeping in touch for 5 years? It doesn't matter how you spin it (was he saving Ra-ra from the heartache of watching a loved one wither away?), most viewers will come away with negative feelings. What would you prefer? To be told someone you loved one had died and live without him for 5 years. Or be told he is sick and be by his side to provide aid and comfort while enjoying his companionship and hopefully recovering? Basic humanity solves this simple question. What on earth were the writers trying to achieve? Tacking on a crude Hollywood-type happy ending undercut the magic of this show.
So let’s propose a couple of alternative endings.
Alternative 1; He’s dead. Leave it at that. It’s still a sweet love story with a bittersweet ending that mature adults could appreciate.
Alternative 2: Mom arrives at the party, reveals Joon’s illness and that he’s too sick to travel. Ra-ra goes to visit. That sets up two possibilities for the epilogue: Five years later, they’re married with a kid studying the piano and playing their homecoming song on their wedding anniversary. Or five years later, Joon has died, but she had his child who is learning to play the piano, starting with the homecoming song. (And of course, Mimi the Dog is there playing the piano when nobody is looking.)
Your pick, sweet or bittersweet (I like the latter), both work much better.
Also, did anyone else feel Mimi got the short shrift? This charismatic dog was a scene stealer. We needed her in more episodes.
And while we're critiquing the show, one scene in particular was just embarrassingly stupid. Suspecting her father's business associate had committed fraud, Ra-ra tracks him down, finding him in a car at parking lot where she observes him abusing his wife. When Ra-ra confronts him, he informs her he had become an actor and they were, in actuality, just filming a scene.
Really? So you mean to tell me Ra-ra didn't notice a film crew and equipment nearby?
Not buying it.
Having said all this, it was still a great show.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Ending Explained (My Theory)
I know so many people who are upset with the ending because they take it literally, when it should be taken metaphorically and then it wouldn’t be so horrible.I think that even though she looks the same, all the comments on the FL being old and such are trying to clue the viewers into the fact that she’s finished with her life. We already saw the flashback scenes suggesting reincarnation. This story has been told before, basically.
I think that she dies at the end, and then is reunited with him in heaven.
Was this review helpful to you?